Medical: is provided by private companies like Kaiser, who have proven their ability to grow as their customer base grows.
Kindergarten: the school district has excess capacity, as # students has shrunk from 70k+ to fewer than 50k. They will probably need to close some schools to increase utilization.
Streets: the streets in San Francisco are way less crowded than anywhere else I've lived.
Public transport: the last few times I've taken the bus, it's been easy to find a seat. The last time I took the BART it was nearly empty.
Schools: see comment above.
I'm ex-bay area since 2016, but I recall standing room only BART and shoulder-to-shoulder CALTRAIN can't add another body when heading to south bay. Although I didn't take SF bus, or send kids to Kindergarten.
The enrollment dropped from 2019 to now, but by something like 5k (on my phone and don't have the exact stats handy).
My anecdotes about the last few journeys I took are recent, not from 2019. But, even in 2019, my experience of public transport in San Francisco was that it was far less crowded than that in London, New York or Beijing.
SF's roads are not congested. If buses were to become crowded due to increased population, we could just buy more buses and increase the frequency. This would keep crowding at current levels, whilst reducing wait times, thus making buses far more convenient than they are today.
Regarding Caltrain: if SF had more housing, fewer people who work in SF would need to live outside and take Caltrain in.
> Public transport: the last few times I've taken the bus, it's been easy to find a seat. The last time I took the BART it was nearly empty.
if that is the case, SF has either the most amazing public transportation already or the most under-used public transportation. or you are simply cheery-picking.
school, kindergarten and medical need to be in close vicinity though. the overall capacity is meaningless for the first two if you build housing for an additional 15k within a few blocks and then have no GPs (and to a lesser extend consultants) within a few minutes of walking or no hospital within a quick driving distance. and if that 70k to 50k (i assume it is not covid related) is uniformly across all kindergartens, it is pretty meaningless for housing
The comment to which you replied was specifically talking about SF so I assumed (reasonably I think) that you were commenting about SF, too.
"if that is the case, SF has either the most amazing public transportation already or the most under-used public transportation. or you are simply cheery-picking."
Those are not the only explanations. And, given I said live in SF, maybe it's reasonable to assume I'm reporting actual observations, unless I've previously demonstrated some pattern of exaggeration.
- I happened to get lucky on my last 5 journeys
- Many people how have more flexibility about when they start/end work, even if they're not working remotely
- People are avoiding public transport due to worries about COVID and increasing crime
- Outside of peak hours, buses still need to run with some minimum frequency to be a viable option, so they often run empty or with only 1-5 passengers
You could come up with others...
Where exactly do you think schooling and medical practices happen or children are taken care of?
>Public transport
How hard is to coordinate to double the number of trains or buses?
> Streets
I don't know what you mean by the demand of streets increases.
Most times solving the housing problem is a lack of will or coordination, and the solution is muddled/deleted/delayed indefinitely by arguments like this.
So it's even more efficient with higher population.
in close vicinity of the housing. not sure i understand the question.
> How hard is to coordinate to double the number of trains or buses?
running a bus during peak hours at twice your current rate (unless the rate is completely ridicilous) does not sound easy. why do you assume it is? at that rate, for SF at least, you are talking subway.
by streets i meant the higher volume during peak hours that need to be sustained (walking, cycling, driving, busses, trams, parking etc).
The 14R (the fastest bus from my home to downtown SF) is scheduled to run every 10 mins (on average) during the morning peak.
Running that bus every 5 mins (which presents no special difficulty) would double the capacity, and reduce average wait time by 5 mins.
I didn't mention trams.
I wasn't making a general case that's applicable to every city.
I was talking about specifically about SF, which has relatively uncongested roads, bus lanes that are mostly empty, and where the busiest bus stops receive buses no more than ~10 times per hour.
> Running that bus every 5 mins (which presents no special difficulty) would double the capacity, and reduce average wait time by 5 mins.
the problem with public transportation among other things are connections. running specific buses with a higher frequency does not give you a lower wait time (on the journey) but only on that stop.
> I didn't say every bus. > I didn't mention trams.
ok i don't get it. why did you bring this up at all then?