What to do if the .com domain for your idea is taken? | Hacker News Reader

What to do if the .com domain for your idea is taken?

7 pointsskcin720 comments

I have been working on my first idea for a startup for 3 years now (most of time spent just teaching myself how to code... i only knew basic html back then). The name I have for my startup I am pretty firm with, though unfortunately the domain is taken. It's just 4 letters long (no vowels) so you can imagine that it is taken. What do you think the best way is to handle this situation?

I was thinking:

A) Get a top-level domain such as .net or .info?

B) Get a country code level domain such as .us or .cc?

C) Lookup the information of the current owner and try to buy it from them

D) Keep the same name but add something to the end of it, e.g. "burgersapp.com" instead of "burgers.com" (if it's an app for burgers)

E) Think of a different name for your product

F) Something else (please explain)

View on HN

F) Go to Google Translate, type in variations of your desired domain in English, then try out most of the languages until you get a short, pronounceable, memorable word or phrase, then register thatphrase.com.

English: hack me, hackme.com, not available.

Danish: hack mig, hackmig.com, available.

Icelandic: hakk mig, hakkmig.com, available.

Indonesian: hack saya, hacksaya.com, available.

Norwegian: hack meg, hackmeg.com, available.

Swedish: hacka mig, hackamig.com, available.

Bonus: you get to make up some cool, interesting back story.

Wow....that is a great idea... I am going to use this method tomorrow!

F) http://domai.nr

your name being 4 letters makes that less useful than it would be otherwise.

So D) is probably your best bet for the reason pavpanchekha and Joakal already suggested: if you're successful you can buy the original domain name you wanted like dropbox, mint, facebook, twitter, etc.

Maybe try getting the same 4 letters twice in a row if that works...

Definitely try to buy it. A good domain is well worth it.

Probably though it'll be too expensive (unless you have significant funding).

Keep it mind that it's extremely easy to convince yourself that a particular domain is The One. It really truly never is. It's really hard, but you can find another one that's good (often better).

We were in the same situation and settled for mispelledword.net while we were in dev - until we stumbled onto an auction for the word.com and picked it up for ~$2k. We were incredibly lucky though.

If you can't reach them or don't have the budget and that name is The One go with D.

I'd go with option D - if your app takes off, you'll be making enough money to buy the "proper" domain. That, or use a random word generator to create a brand name. Protip: if you go down this road, do a Google first just in case it means something unexpected :)

I vote for D since trying to buy domain name from owner could be expensive and not worth going for it

Add something to the unavailable domain is my preference D, but what ever you add, don't make it too long, try to keep it around 8 chars max

There are lots of successful apps with great names and less-than-ideal URLs - 37 Signals seem to be doing just fine with BasecampHQ.com, HighriseHQ.com, CampfireNow.com and BackpackIt.com. I use BeanstalkApp.com and PostmarkApp.com.

How do you mean, "if"?

spell it differently

whats the space? think of an alternate name.

Is the .com you like doing the same thing as you?

    A) Get a top-level domain such as .net or .info?
    B) Get a country code level domain such as .us or .cc?

.org is better - there's wikipedia, craigslist, wordpress, thepiratebay, all in top 100.

If you look at alexa top sites, there's not a single .net or .info site in the top 100.

First .net site: secureserver.net (106th place)

First .info site: com-net.info (807th place)

First .us site: imageshack.us (132th place)

First .cc site: wretch.cc (287th place)

    C) Lookup the information of the current owner and try to buy it from them

Assuming you can find them and they answer the email filled in their whois.

    D) Keep the same name but add something to the end of it, 
    e.g. "burgersapp.com" instead of "burgers.com" (if it's an 
    app for burgers)

No.

    E) Think of a different name for your product

That's definitely one of the best ways, if rebranding is not an issue. Notice that most of the top websites have completely made up names that don't say much about the business - google, youtube, yahoo, linkedin, amazon.

    F) Something else (please explain)

Check out domain auctions, you might find something short and sweet for a reasonable price.

  D) ...
  No

I wouldn't be so glib. Didn't Dropbox start at getdropbox.com and only buy dropbox.com a year or two ago? Worked for them.

GetMint.com and TheFacebook.com, both made deals to buy out the domain iirc.

I believe it was mymint.com

Facebook also had to pay $100,000 to buy the .com. That's not really a possibility for most of us.

And if they won't sell them at a reasonable price, you're stuck with an ugly domain name.

Not necessarily. I don't think SquareUp.com is horrific or anything if they never end up acquiring Square.com. It's not ideal but it doesn't have to be horrific either.

If the ideal name is four letters with no vowels then I'm not sure a few extra letters are that much worse

Even if the entire focus of my app was brevity I'd be very happy with tldrapp.com, tldrhub.com or sorrytldr.com (all available) as names :)

Option C worked well for us. There is no harm in trying.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com