> First we make N complex values from polar coordinates that have a random angle 0 to 2pi and a random radius from 0 to 1.
This is what jumped out to me as suspicious. This looks just like a naive (and wrong) algorithm for generating random points in a circle. The simplest correct way to do this in the circle case is rejection sampling. In this context, that would mean: generate a random real and imaginary part to get z, and retry until |z| ≤ 1.