UK Inches Closer to Eliminating Private Car Ownership
motorious.com
motorious.com
But as someone who used to live in the uk where car ownership was practically forced on you due to economic reasons and seeing the destruction of public transport such that you should see a trip to the next city akin to taking a flight to another country, fuck em.
A car is a huge expense, i won’t lie and say it doesn’t have advantages, like if you have a family, but i’m single, and now i live in a country with an expansive public transport system and i realised, actually, car ownership is just passing on the cost of a public transport system to the general public at a huge cost to themselves.
I have a shared car scheme where i can rent a car by the hour, they have stations everywhere and i use it like twice a year to go to ikea.
I can’t go out with a car and drink, i have to find parking spaces, i cannot do anything productive while driving a car and i’m of the opinion that anyone who drives to work is on work time while doing it, mostly unpaid.
I take frequent taxis, but adding up the cost of all those is nowhere comparable to the cost of a car, sitting idle in a garage that would also cost me extra each month.
Car ownership was forced on us.
Before this I lived in London where a bus stop was 2 minutes walk away and a tube train just ten minutes. Bot outside London and cities that have trams like Sheffield, Nottingham and Manchester, public transport is just not to be found.
https://www.express.co.uk/life-style/cars/1538656/car-owners...
I can't quite figure out where the got the idea of a ban from, but they're very angry about it.
Undeniably.
> death, and injury,
Let me frame it this way: “Guns don’t kill people. People do.”
> all while providing poor-quality transportation for a high price to a subset of the population.
I don’t know. I’m pretty happy with the quality of transportation I get out of my car. I can go anywhere I want at any time I want regardless of the weather. It saves me time and I’m happy to pay for that convenience. But I don’t own a car, I lease it.
I think it's actually worse than your framing suggests, even though it's generally recognized that widespread gun ownership is very poor for public health. Guns kill people by providing the means for people with the intent and opportunity to kill. Cars provide both the means and the opportunity, while making the intent irrelevant.
Operating heavy machinery at high speeds in public spaces is an inherently risky thing. It is no surprise then, that deaths from automobiles are consistently in the top ten deaths-by-cause for every developed nation. Expecting people to maintain the degree of focus and discipline necessary to operate heavy machinery in streets shared with children, elderly and cyclists, without safety barriers, at high speeds, is obviously a bad idea, unless you're willing to accept a lot of children, elderly, and cyclists dying.
Which is "worse" doesn't matter. He framed it that way because while cars do make it much easier for a hapless peasant to put the kinetic energy of a few thousand pounds at high speed somewhere it has no business being the overwhelming majority of cars will never be in that situation and many societies have decided that the benefits of widespread accessibility outweigh those costs.
>while making the intent irrelevant.
Please explain. And please do a better job than "I don't like cars so therefore we should apply really strict standards to it the way we do with hazardous activities like blasting, fumigation of dwellings, etc,". Why do you want those standards applied and why are cars so deserving?
Children (0-14) are also least likely to die, and it seems that young male drivers are most at risk. Elderly (65+) seem to die in the same numbers as young drivers.
Now, I am open to your claim that whatever the numbers are today, they are a lot.
But most deaths occur outside cities where cars are going at much higher speeds, so the essence of your argument is nothing but spreading FUD, and won't help in a reasonable debate.
There are also other economic aspects (how many people would not have gotten engineering jobs, and would public transport ever evolve to this extent without the funding for private vehicles...), but I am happy to ignore that for the sake of your argument (basically, it's a what-if).
I'd also be interested to see the age-vs-death stats for the US split up by user group. In Germany, the pedestrians and cyclists most likely to die are over 75.
[0]: https://www.itf-oecd.org/sites/default/files/germany-road-sa...
I think even in the US case, I would see it as unacceptable that somebody who doesn't take part in a risky practice (driving) is still exposed to the risk. The difference in likelyhood of death, after all, is not between a pedestrian and a driver, but between a pedestrian in a world with cars, and one without them.
In the US case, I think there's a stronger argument for cars simply because cities have been built around them, so switchover costs would be higher. There are also arguments for using cars for deliveries. On the other hand, using them for mass transport in dense urban areas is insane.
It's like all new people joining a legacy project shouting let's refactor everything! You fix the obvious problems with the current system and reintroduce problems that the old system did well.
At the end of the day, radical change is necessary. We are facing catastrophic climate change. Cutting back (or indeed getting rid of) cars is one of the more painless things you can do in many cities. This is not like a legacy project, where it ultimately still delivers a service to customers in a buggy-but-functional manner. This is a runaway locomotive that absolutely has to be stopped somehow, and the challenge is to stop it in the least painful way possible.
If climate-change-induced-by-cars is a "runaway locomotive", you can solve that differently (eg. electric vehicles). Eliminating them from cities will probably not solve the climate-change effect they have either (most distance travelled is outside cities, including in Germany), but only the local pollution they cause.
If you care about cyclist and pedestrian experience, you can solve that in another way (dedicated lanes and better road design, driver education...).
Finally, congestion is a symptom and not a cause: it's the effect of people needing to get from a bunch of places into another set of places. Anyone who's ever travelled on public transport during rush hour anywhere heavily populated has experienced the same thing (eg. can't get into a subway train due to it being over-crowded).
You also seem to ignore the "fringe" 10% of the population (I made that number up, obviously, to indicate a small proportion, but even in Germany, that would make it millions of people) that currently has no access to public transport in a way they need (if they need to switch 5 transportation vehicles to get to work in 2h with this "painless" switch, it's not very "painless"). This is why I mention "relocation" in my previous post because that may be the only viable option to not make them spend 12h outside their homes for work purposes, and costs of relocation can be prohibitive.
Basically, you are either being purposely ignorant of the issues at hand or simply have the overconfidence of someone clueless jumping into a legacy project.
None of it is painless, or it would have been done ages ago. I admit that we sometimes do need overconfident, clueless people to enact a change, but sometimes we do not.
If I'm ignoring a '10%' of the population, it is probably that portion (in reality, much more than 10%) that cannot drive, for medical, age, or economic reasons, who gain absolutely nothing from cars, but nonetheless subsidize their usage (taxes to maintain roads, etc).
The root of the problem is physical: moving about a ton of metal, glass and plastic for every passenger is extremely inefficient. Having a single engine for every passenger is extremely inefficient. Taking several square meters of road space for every passenger is extremely inefficient. These inefficiencies are at the root of why they produce a lot of CO2, a lot of local pollution, and yes, a lot of congestion. Using road space inefficiently obviously causes more congestion.
Obviously, it would take a concerted effort to bring public transport to the level where it could replace cars for all users. That said, if we imagine the intense social changes that cars brought about (the building of the suburbs, clearing people off the streets, etc) I think it would be comparatively mild, and compared to cars in cost, just going by the rule of thumb that inefficiencies ultimately cost money, it should be cheaper.
I am with you that cars are maybe an avoidable convenience, especially in urban areas. But congestion happens without them too (if defined liberally, overcrowded trains you cannot get into are exactly the same as congestion, or at least have the same delaying effect for your trip), and cars can be used outside of congested hours and routes too. So they are not at the nexus of that problem.
But roads where I am at usually detoriate faster where buses go (bus lanes need reconstruction more often), so while we'd need fewer roads if we switched exclusively to heavy vehicles, they'd need more maintenance: I am not convinced it would save on road maintenance just from throwing empty claims (neither yours nor mine) around on the internet.
We've rehashed this already and I guess we need to agree to disagree: I see both benefits and drawbacks to cars, and while you claim to back the underprivileged by (almost) demanding car bans, I believe they'd be hardest hit outside urban areas instead.
1. Capitalism is already centralized. Jobs tend to be concentrated in certain areas. That's why people commute.
2. The suburban-commuter lifestyle is based on very high fossil fuel usage, since it is more energy-intensive, both in terms of transport, but also service provision. There are no economies of scale anywhere in the system (e.g for heating and insulation).
It's obviously possible to electrify all the cars, insulate all the houses, and continue this faux-decentralized sprawling approach to living, but it would be an uphill struggle, and far more difficult than just recognizing that, as a lifestyle, it should be expensive, because it has expensive externalities and requires a lot of expensive energy inputs. If you priced in carbon costs to the suburban lifestyle, instead of subsidizing it in a thousand subtle ways, almost nobody would be able to afford it. Even if you simply stopped subsidizing it, it would probably decline as a culture[0]. And it should decline, because it is wasteful and implicitly damaging to nature[1].
Other stuff that's on the table for fighting climate change (decarbonizing steel, electrifying everything, decarbonizing concrete, etc) is just way more drastic and expensive than just discouraging a style of living that necessitates an enormous amount of resource usage. What's more, all the drastic changes require frontloading CO2 emissions - and because global temperatures are a positive feedback loop, that's way worse than releasing CO2 later.
[0]: E.g. Service provision costs more when density goes down, because you have to lay more cables, hire more police, run more pipe, etc. If they pay the same taxes as everybody else, that is a subsidy. There are a lot of examples like that.
[1]: The simple presence of so many humans and their pets is a driver of declining biodiversity, sans any considerations of all the hummers.
PS: If you're wondering how I would 'discourage' suburban living, I'd just do the same thing they did to cities in the post-new-deal US. Cut service provision. Cut police presence. Don't repair the roads. Make the suburbs subsidize the inner city, instead of the other way around.
What you are talking about is not about cars though, it's about changing the entire lifestyle of humanity. If only the rich can have their private gardens, then we'd need a lot more gardens (parks) in urban areas, perhaps some of them with private spaces for when you need some solitude. You are also going to discourage a new trend: work from home (though it's not so new for some of us, I've been WFH since 2006).
All of your premises about subsidizing cars are false, in my opinion. Unless you move all people close to where they work, we need public infrastructure that's harder to maintain (as I said, buses destroy roads more than cars do) than what we already have for cars. And while we might need less of it, we'd still need more than what we need for buses and trucks today since more people and needs would move to use them, so it's not so certain we'd be spending less on maintaining and building it.
You keep talking about energy optimization. Most optimal for energy use is hardly most optimal for human well-being. Shared apartments would definitely be most optimal: you only need a private sleeping room, and only if you are a family. Otherwise, why would you mind having a bunk bed in a bedroom that has 6 of them? This would optimize building, heating and cooling costs. Sharing kitchens or even cooking meals centrally (say, for an apartment block) and distributing to tenants would be even more optimal. I hope you don't want your own kitchen when it's more optimal to have someone cook a large quantity at once.
It's easy to see where that is going, and that's not the future I want to live in. It's been a theme of not just one dystopic book or story or movie.
While people frequently bring up an argument that humans are already taking up too much space on this planet, they fail to remember that it's not because of our settlements. It's mostly because of agriculture. Human settlements are a tiny fraction of the land we use for agriculture, and sprawling settlements are not the biggest issue (sure, they are an issue locally where humans might be pushing other species out, but not so much on a global scale).
So, while you proclaim how getting rid of cars will solve a bunch of problems (CO2 included, even though cars contribute 6% of CO2 emissions annually[1]), I don't see it. And I don't buy the subsidy argument either (fuel throughout Europe is taxed at at least twice the price: compare prices in EU vs US): it's an attempt to attribute entirety of the cost for infrastructure to cars when we'd need some of that infrastructure anyway.
[1] As per https://ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector#energy-electr..., all road transport contributes 11.9%, of which 60% is passenger transport which includes other forms of road transport like buses