Nationally, I'm not sure Congress can force non-taxation on the sates, I think that's a constitutional issue. I think Amazon's plan there is just to use their market dominance and hope the states fold.
Nationally, I'm not sure Congress can force non-taxation on the sates, I think that's a constitutional issue. I think Amazon's plan there is just to use their market dominance and hope the states fold.
I suspect Amazon sees the way things are going and (as in other states) have tried to get what forbearance they can while they can, and also expect a national harmonization of cross-state sales taxes at some point.
It would be virtually impossible for California to win in court on the grounds of A9, A2Z, Alexa, or Amazon AWS having offices in California. None of those companies are involved in Amazon.com's separate retail business.
If Amazon's technique was legally unassailable, they wouldn't be paying sales tax even in the 5 states where they already do. They'd just assign whatever creates 'nexus' in those states to new 'non-selling' subsidiaries.
Amazon can maintain arms-length relations with most of their subsidiaries because those subsidiaries are not part of Amazon's core business, and can operate semi-independently with little to no loss in efficiency.
Maintaining such a relationship with subsidiaries directly involved in the day-to-day operations of Amazon's retail business (maintaining stock, setting prices, making sales, packing and shipping product, etc.) would be much more difficult, costly, and risky.
A9 and A2Z are providing software and/or services to Amazon.com which Amazon.com uses in its retail business. This is completely different from A9 and A2Z engaging in that business. They do not buy, sell, distribute, or ship the products Amazon.com does.
So long as Amazon.com maintains arms-length dealings with A9 and A2Z (which is trivially easy for any company with semi-competent legal counsel to accomplish), the ownership of A9 and A2Z is irrelevant to Amazon.com's dealings with California.
Not that it matters. The principles are well-enshrined in the common law system, codified and uncodified. You may think it's ridiculous, but the courts take it seriously.
Amazon and everyone else involved in ecommerce would be a lot happier if there were a unified system/database for dealing with sales taxes in the US. Rates and rules wouldn't necessarily have to be the same, but there at least has to be one system with unified categorization of products and a unified filing mechanism which can be automatically queried, and as long as the merchants use that system in good faith, they would need to be immune to any sort of lawsuit or prosecution for not meeting the actual legal requirements of any particular state/locality.
I think your idea of a unified sales tax database/system is spot on.
This is serious nightmare ... but much less so for a company of Amazon.com's scale than a potentially dangerous to it upstart.
(Note that I don't agree with charging sales tax on mail order purchases; the mail order companies do not benefit from taxes except, say, though that maintain public order, and that's party captured by the delivery companies they use which do pay local taxes (except for, I assume, the USPS, but that's another issue).)
http://onesource.thomsonreuters.com/solutions/indirect-tax/s...
Also, if Reuters has excessive profits, someone will probably make a competitor. That said, it's basically a solved problem, except when companies want to hand wring their way out of paying taxes.
BTW, don't be ridiculous about "hundreds of thousands". Unless you mean thousands. Even TR in their sales literature only mentions 13k tax authorities [1]
[1] http://onesource.thomsonreuters.com/share/solutions/41686/br...
That might be whats behind Amazon's change of heart. This will be difficult for them, but its probably impossible for smaller retailers. It might be expensive in the short term, but it protects them from competition in the long run.
Without endorsing the product, here is one vendor's product page: http://onesource.thomsonreuters.com/solutions/indirect-tax/s...