What do you suggest as an alternative? Index the internet yourself? Web search as a public utility?
The core problem is a disconnect between the knowledge available on the internet and search tools. Indexing is a stop gap to enable the web to be usable without solving this problem, but it is becoming untenable and was always known to be non viable, just treated as a problem for another day. The sheer amount of information online and its disorganization, as well as the misaligned incentives of search tools are beginning to make this once far away manageable problem a day to day reality for all of us, the solution requires an architectural change to the way information is stored and accessed and updated online.