> So if the goal is a very long term thermal interface material, I don’t think pastes are the best. A homogenous solid is likely to last longer.
Arctic Cooling states that MX-5 is guaranteed to keep its performance its for 8 years [0]. Considering this stuff is made to interface with 200W+ CPUs, cooking it dry with a Raspberry Pi is very unlikely.
As I said before, I'm cooking MX-2 in two different systems (Q6600 & i7 3770K) for 8 years, and they didn't lose their transfer performance a bit.
From my experience, thermal pads and solid interfaces do not transfer with the same efficiency and cannot absorb heat spikes as well as a good thermal paste. I run my OrangePi Zero with a thermal pad interface to a small heat-sink and that thing runs uncomfortably hot. I can't transfer data faster than 40mbps for a long time or run CPU intensive stuff, because it gets hot, fast. Its form factor and case doesn't allow for a more robust solution either.
Of course the choice is yours, but in my experience, when compared to older paste, or to ordinary white stuff, current generation stuff is leaps and bounds ahead. Especially, Arctic Cooling.
[0]: https://www.arctic.de/en/MX-5/ACTCP00047A