I have no way to tell how large a kernel of truth this story may contain, but it certainly feels like it could be true.
OK, I could see that. It would explain why there was such a shift between Matrix 1 and Matrix 2/3.
I'd have peferred them to explain how Neo was able to use the "force" against the machines, see their energy while blind, and who's the Zero. Expected a replica of Neo to be used by the machines or something in the lines of "don't be evil" becomes evil, as a critique to modern tech.
That would explain the powers he gets in real world.
I only watched all 3 way back when and was much younger, but the main parts of the plot seemed coherent to me at the time.
And I'm not saying it isn't coherent in that one can't follow from the other, or that you can't find a way to make a linear narrative out of that. I'm just saying it's a very pronounced change in focus/tone/direction, whatever you want to call it. And to me, from the very first time I saw Matrix 2, I had this strong sense of "wow, that came out of nowhere and went off on a weird direction". It felt very disjointed and weird to me all along.
Anyway... not trying to change anyone's mind here. This is obviously pretty subjective. All I can say is that to me, it's very clear that Matrix 2/3 represent a substantially different (albeit related) story than Matrix 1. If anyone disagrees, well, so be it.
A throwaway thing? What?
This is where humanity lives outside the Matrix. This is the dialogue:
NEO Zion?
TANK If this war ended tomorrow, Zion is where the party would be.
NEO It's a city?
TANK The last human city. The only place we got left.
NEO Where is it?
TANK Deep underground. Near the earth's core, where it's still warm. You live long enough, you might even see it.
Further on Zion is mentioned in connection with the warning and later in the even more important topic of the access codes and coming from Tanks mouth:
TANK We can't let that happen, Trinity. Zion is more important than me. Or you, or even Morpheus
Or Agent Smiths:
AGENT SMITH Once Zion is destroyed, there is no need for me to be here. Do you understand? I need the codes. I have to get inside Zion. You have to tell me how.
I mean seriously. I have the feeling you did not pay attention which is the feeling I get from most of the people who are an the hate train. It seems like those people live off the hype for the fight scenes and visual impact of the first movie which none of the others could deliver because the revolution has happened already. But all movies after Matrix had that problem too and it doesn't say anything about the progression of the story of Matrix.
> But the meat of the story is about the drive to free all of humanity from the Marix. In Matrix 2/3 that element entirely disappears and the "resolution" is some sort of truce between the humans and the machines... that doesn't jibe at all with the "destroy the Matrix" idea, IMO.
It doesn't disappear. It is the main part of the story of those movies. The decisions need to do are just about that. This is what is important and the result is a consequence of what happened along the way.
You should really consider watching those movies again because I think you've missed a lot there.
I have watched The Matrix probably 100+ times (and the sequels a good 30 or more times each). I really doubt that I'm the one who's "missing something" here.
Anyway, if you see it differently, then you see it differently. That's totally acceptable. Two people can watch the same movie(s) and reach different interpretations. Nothing unusual about that.
"I can't see how anyone ever thought..."
and end the conversation with:
"Nothing unusual about two people reaching different interpretations. "
Whether the Matrix was intended as 1 movie or 3 movies is inconsequential in the grand scheme, but seeing this side of human nature is kind of interesting and somewhat amusing.
"No one could possibly watch the Matrix and think that..."
I'm just saying I personally don't see the thought process, and the interpretation(s) where the movies are a cleanly connected, smooth, linear, contiguous narrative. I'm not saying that such processes and interpretations can't exist, hence
"Two people can watch the same movie(s) and reach different interpretations."
Anyway...