Hacker News Reader

Comment by bigyellow | Hacker News Reader

Not to mention wood fireplaces in the home and the noxious byproducts they produce is likely to shorten your lifespan considerably.

View on HN

Bah. Freezing to death in an ice storm can also 'shorten your lifespan considerably'. There's damned good reason to want a simple, off grid means of heating your home if you lose power.

This is not the case when using modern wood burning stoves though right?

Apparently they're not as great as people have been thinking

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/dec/18/wood-bur...

Or wood burning fireplace inserts that draw combustion air from outside and expel the fumes/combustion byproducts outside as well. Not ideal for local air quality, but essentially eliminates indoor pollution from them.

Well sure, if you are the only person for miles that uses a fireplace.

Additionally, I think people who are outdoors still have to breathe air.

To that point -- last summer, my friends moved from a mountain town under constant threat of wildfire to a pleasant spot by a lake in the Midwest -- their new neighbor keeps a fire burning 24/7, so they still get to enjoy the terrible air quality all winter long.

Unless it does turn wood into a pure gas without a trace of sulfur, silica etc. it must emit such stuff. Or it comes with filters cleaning fine particles, nitric oxide etc. In the end it does emit CO2.

Wood pellets largely solve this.

the smoke goes up the chimney.

Most of the smoke goes up the chimney. You still open it to light, relight and sweep away the ash and in that time you're going to breathe in some smoke or dust particles which you ideally shouldn't

Mine's gone out...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com