How is not disclosing a salary range in itself discriminatory? I can see how it could enable discrimination, but cannot connect the dots about how it is, in itself, an act of discrimination.
How is not disclosing a salary range in itself discriminatory? I can see how it could enable discrimination, but cannot connect the dots about how it is, in itself, an act of discrimination.
It's discriminatory as a matter of law because the law defining it says so.
It's practically not inherently discriminatory, but it's a technique which increases the opportunity and difficulty of proving arbitrary discrimination, including on prohibited grounds, and which serves no other purpose other than enabling difficult to certainly identify (by the target) discrimination (both on prohibited grounds and otherwise).
It also allows me to pay you less because you're not a critical thinker. But yeah, it's probably discriminatory. We don't want to hurt your ego.
If you can't figure out how to design your screening to objectively measure, sort, & select for that desired criteria, you have no business discriminating pay rates based on it.
And if you CAN & DO have a screening system that does so, you can prove you are not discriminating by making offers strongly correlated to scores in your screening system, e.g., "Strong candidates get offers $X-$Y, Exceptional=115% of Strong, Good=85% of Strong, Acceptable = 75%, lower=no offer" (presuming your screening system doesn't also include other explicitly/implicitly discriminatory criteria).
Edit: To be clear, I did not mean to accuse you of fear-mongering; I think the politicians are dressing this policy up to make themselves look better.
It's like how a pidfd is a file descriptor. Is Linux saying a process is a file? No, but it's saying that the usual things that apply to file descriptors - how you pass them around, how you name them, etc. - also apply to pidfds, and anything that works with file descriptors in the future should probably also work with pidfds. It's not saying that OS professors should teach "Really, a process is a kind of file." In the same way, philosophy professors should not, on the basis of this law alone, say "Really, refusing to post salary ranges is discrimination."
(And a "discriminatory practice" is a specific abstraction separate from but usually connected with "discrimination" in much the same way that a "file descriptor" is a specific abstraction separate from but usually connected with "files".)
How dare the government define what '3rd degree theft' means! My liberty to define that myself has being stolen!
If you wanted to pay people who wear purple scarves less, the first thing you'd need to be able to do is make sure that the purple scarf wearers and non-wearers had no easy way to compare salaries.
That's why this is a step against discrimination: it bans a practice that can be used to discriminate (though it may not be used that way).