You've never experienced a decent subway then. The king of Norway famously rode the subway during an oil crisis. Outside of America, they are not seen as dirty, or dangerous, just as another way to get around...
I have actually. The ones in Korea and Japan were excellent. Thats why I specifically mentioned the US. I'm not sure why there is a such a stark difference (cultural reasons?) but it remains the public transit in most of the US is a terrible experience.
Singaporean subways/trains are also excellent IME. However the Singaporean people seem to think it's inadequate - I thought it was fantastic compared to the public transport systems we have in Australia.