The time has come to get on with our lives
spectator.co.uk
spectator.co.uk
> Workers cannot permanently be kept away from their offices.
And yet, I keep reading about companies that postpone their "back to office" dates again and again because workers have adapted to home office and are refusing to come back.
The Spectator author doesn't seem to have similar reasons. Nothing in the article makes me think that he'd arrive at the opposite conclusion if any fact about the world were different.
The natural immune system is a borderline conspiracy theory to these people.
Corporate news media and big pharma are much more trustworthy.
Today they are perfect, they can do no wrong, it's highly immoral to question them, their motives and their products. It's crazy. It's a bit like living in an ongoing The Onion article.
The misinformation has reached the highest levels.
We live in a continuous Onion article.
They lied about Covid have also been lying about inflation.
And we're about to pay the price.
We're at 70% vaccination rate and we have double the number of cases we did at the height of the pandemic.
Mask mandates haven't worked, quarantines don't work, locking down entire countries doesn't work.
It's time to accept that this is endemic and not make Covid the center of everyone's existence any longer.
The one thing we should do more of is testing, and that's precisely because they allow more targeted action. Identifying and isolating infected individuals avoids the need (or temptation) for broader restrictions on whole classes of places or events. Vaccine and/or testing requirements would create more freedom for a lot of people, not less, but somehow that fact gets lost in the noise from people who are already least affected. "Just give up" is a pretty severe sentence for the people you don't see.
More people than EVER are vaccinated and we have higher case loads than ever.
I don't understand how you can still justify this line of thinking in 2022.
Having it as an option is fine. Mandating people to take something that the experts are not even sure how effective it is?
Two thirds of the country are vaccinated and that had NO impact on case rates?
Instead case rates doubled?
Your understanding (or acceptance) of a statement does not reflect at all on its truth. Immunocompromised people still exist. People with other risk factors (including those that aren't even the result of any choice they made) still exist. Children too young to be vaccinated still exist. Their families and others in constant close contact with them still exist. After the omicron wave has abated, as it has already done in South Africa and is likely to do elsewhere, all those people will still be barred from doing things that they could otherwise do within a reasonable margin of safety if vaccine and testing requirements were in place. It's really not that complicated. Their freedom is being limited by others' intransigence.
As for whether experts know if the vaccines are effective: they do.
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMc2119270
It's entirely possible to have higher numbers of cases despite vaccines being effective, if the number of exposures and/or infectivity have increased more than the vaccination rate and effectiveness. Again, it's not that complicated. The math is pretty simple, people have done the math (see above), and the only rational conclusion is that vaccines are pretty effective.
Second of all, If you're born without an immune system...that sucks...but no one's problem but yours. Get a bubble suit, be creative. That's what America's all about.
Concerts and arena sports are still going on daily dispute highest caseloads ever.
People as a whole, have moved past your way of thinking with the manipulative: "what about immunocompromised children and granny" heartstring stuff.
People want to see Coachella or the Lakers and live their lives... despite an immunocompromised child or granny dying.
They aren't going to stand for questionable vaccines and questionable Covid restrictions any longer.
Society wide, for all intents and purposes, Covid is over being the center of people life anymore.
What the supreme court will rule on is not whether the facts I've laid out are correct. What they will rule on is whether it is permissible under the constitution to take action that will weigh one small group's major freedoms for another larger group's minor ones. That's quite a different thing. Some might even argue that what the court will decide, given its current makeup, is whether they can find an excuse to do what one political faction wants, and that's different again.
> If you're born without an immune system...that sucks...but no one's problem but yours
That is an extremely callow position, supported by neither the law nor the popular will. The US constitution, among others, was written as part of a philosophical tradition in which protection of society's most vulnerable was a high moral value. Its content and subsequent interpretation reflect that, as do vast numbers of statutes passed under it. What you're arguing for is nothing less than eugenics, and that's not just a "manipulating heartstrings" issue. It's almost universally reviled, for good reason.
> People as a whole, have moved past
Appeal to popularity, fallacious and false.
> They aren't going to stand for questionable vaccines
You haven't provided one shred of evidence calling those vaccines' efficacy (or safety) into question. Haven't even tried. On the other hand, evidence proving that efficacy has been provided. Any good-faith interlocutor would be able to make better arguments.
You didnt wear a mask before the pandemic which spreads deadly flu and other respiratory diseases so you're contributing to eugenics which is very callow of you.
It's not eugenics if it's naturally present in the environment like covid or the flu.
> The US constitution, among others, was written as part of a philosophical tradition in which protection of society's most vulnerable was a high moral value
The constitution said colored people were 2/3 of a person, slaves, and women weren't allowed to vote. Not sure you want to go down that road.
> What they will rule on is whether it is permissible under the constitution to take action that will trade off one group's freedoms for another's.
Well that's the fundamental argument.
Does protecting the tiny fraction of those vulnerable to Covid warrant the vast majority of society giving up their freedoms.
You say it does others say it doesn't.
The fact that the Lakers are playing in an arena and Coachella is happening means society as a whole gave your line of thinking a chance...realized it didn't work..and decided you're wrong.
>You haven't provided one shred of evidence calling those vaccines' efficacy (or safety) into question.
If two thirds of the population is vaccinated and case counts haven't decreased but in fact have have DOUBLED thats very suspicious sounding to me.
>That is an extremely callow position,
Did you wear a mask before the pandemic to protect immunocomprosed children and granny from the flu which kills tens of thousands per year?
If not, that seems like pretty callow behavior of you. Who knows how many people died as a result of you passing on a disease. You really should wear a mask and ideally quarantine as much as possible forever to minimize risk to others.
You were the one who brought up the supreme court - a constitutional body - as though they're the ultimate authority. You went down that road. Since that failed spectacularly, I guess it's no surprise that you're trying to abandon it and poison the well behind you.
> Does protecting the tiny fraction of those vulnerable to Covid warrant the vast majority of society giving up their freedoms.
It's not a tiny fraction, and their freedoms are lost otherwise. Why do you keep ignoring that, and them? This isn't just a unilateral loss of freedom; it's a tradeoff. There's even precedent from prior vaccine mandates, suggesting that the amount of freedom gained vs. the amount of freedom lost allows them. You've still failed to provide any basis by which such long standing and universally accepted (hardly any challenges) precedent should be overturned now.
> If two thirds of the population is vaccinated and case counts haven't decreased
The basic math behind that has already been explained to you. Why would you expect anyone to engage further or take you seriously when you just repeat ridiculous claims instead of addressing prior refutations?
Acknowledged numerous times. My question for you...
What percentage of the population having a problem, makes it so the rest of society is responsible for them?
When does it cross from an problem that a small group of people have like Aids or sickle cell to a problem that the entirety of society is responsible for?
What percentage is fair for you?
5%? 10%?
What percentage is fair to ask someone not to leave their house and to wear the equivalent of a face burka and to not have physical contact with people and to not have social activities?
What percentage justifies this to you?
No it has not.
I agree that we're all pretty fed up but you aren't offering any constructive guidance whatsoever. Not even "repeal all mandates, let people do whatever the fuck they want everywhere unvaccinated and unmasked", for example.
If you want to wear a mask wear one if you want to get a vaccine get one if you want to quarantine quarantine.
There's nothing humans can do to make this virus go away and all of these measures clearly aren't as effective as sold to us and the data is not as clear as people are led to believe.
The CDC continuously changes it's policies, the vaccine continuously changes it's effectiveness and durability, none of the data of anything justifying these restrictions is as clear as we're led to believe.
But if it's something that you want to do go for it!
E.g. "the measures aren't as effective as we hoped" doesn't mean they're completely ineffective. "The data aren't as clear" doesn't mean the data are completely useless. "The virus mutates and is more complex than we thought" doesn't mean its nature is beyond our understanding and we'll never be able to get the upper hand.
One thing we agree on is that the CDC has dropped the ball far too many times, and has largely forfeited the trust that many people had in its guidance. Ironically (for your argument) is that this is precisely because it has acted against basic logic and against measures which (though imperfect) do largely work.
But it simply doesn't follow that, just because one agency in the U.S. has become unreliable in its pronouncements -- that we can't rely on any basic science at all; that there's no hope of slowing this thing down or of staunching the tide of death and misery; and at land there's no point in attempting to get any kind of social consensus on basic measures (which while imperfect, are still largely effective) to do so.
Because none of it is working.
And Coachella is happening and the Lakers are playing in their arena and the rest of society has accepted that Covid is endemic and moved on past Covid as the religion that demands sacrifice.
The puritanical Covid world is ending.
https://oliverbeige.medium.com/how-citing-dunning-kruger-sho...
Is this a major news site, or someone’s first blog post?
Surely the writer could do better, and surely the editor could’ve insisted on it.