The networking layer isn't gonna change. That's given. Any change at the ISP level needs to be driven by policy decisions. But at the hardware/software-level? All of that is made up, and we could build much easier systems for network administration and app deployment.
people running their own servers would/might have given rise to a more decentralized system in which the putative problems web3 is claimed to fix would not have arisen.
> Hopefully Web3 reaches the point that there's a 1-click installer, like downloading an app, that does everything you need it to do, so people can enjoy all of the things they want from the web with the benefits of decentralization.
As long as web3 depends on everyone running their own server (or using someone else's server), i don't see why we would expect anything to change.
The promise of web 3 is to come up with new distributed protocols that allow people to have the same kind of functionality as today, but without having to cede control to FB/Google/MS etc. The reality of web 3 is probably closer to Moxie's article: these distributed protocols are actually closer to email infrastructure than to that promise, and the result will likely be similar to web 2: one or two major platforms will grow and offer a nice interface with the complex distributed network, and the vast majority of people will actually interact with the proprietary platform, not the underlying distributed protocol.
Let's contrast my "summary":
> "IF people had ended up running their own servers from 94 onwards, we might not have gotten into this situation".
with your analysis:
> the only solution [ ... ] to have a decentralized web where most content is not in the hands of a small handful of mega corporations is for everyone to run their own web servers
Maybe we're reading this somehow very differently, but to me these looks at worst highly compatible points, and at best, the same point.
But I also agree with your summary in your 2nd paragraph.
I'm reading a nuance difference into it - the first statement, to me, sounds like it puts some blame on the people, while the second one (and, I believe, Moxie's article) puts the blame on the technologies that forced this situation.