Agree. I suspect the difference of opinion might be down to systems like Javadoc, that transform code comments into API docs. But Javadoc comments are often auto-generated from function prototypes, which results in Javadoc comments that add nothing to the raw code except bloat. I don't think I'ver ever seen good documentation produced from doc-comments.
There's another thread on the front page about literate programming; I suspect that doc-comments amount to an effort to weave code and documentation together, in a knuthian manner, to kind-of automate literate programming. It doesn't work, AFAICS. You get bloated code and bad docs.