I was leaning more towards the web approach where we assume everyone is out to get us, but they can't unless we give them that one permission they need. If it's a statically typed language then it'd even allow dependency walking to see what permissions are used at a granular level and we can decide not to bring in anything that's too loose. This of course won't solve cases like logic bugs, but it'd help mitigate the impact.
I'm just not sure if it's even feasible?