The advice I give to 99% of people is if you get into YC you should definitely do it, but the valuation is not necessarily high.
The reason to go through YC is, quite simply, they will increase the value of your company by significantly more than 7%. If you don't believe they can add that much value, then you shouldn't do it. There aren't many people who don't think YC can add that though, just the valuation bump you'll get while fundraising is significantly greater. And on top of that they really do a great job of actually helping you, which alone is worth the 7% in my opinion.
This is extra pro rata.
If the next priced round is at $7.5M, their $375K converts at that price (so it buys them another 5%). If your next round is not above $1.8M, it’s already an unfavorable sign.
The only downside I see is it doesn’t let you raise another small amount without valuing YC’s follow-on $375K. You might want to do such a raise for strategic rather than financial reasons and this would be an overhang against that. (I don’t think it’s that big a deal in practice and the additional committed money is probably better by way more than this detriment.)
So the first tranche values your company at 1.78 million; if, afterwards, you raise more money at 6 million valuation, YC gets another 6.25% for 375k.
Correct me if I'm wrong.