Personally, I’d rather buy my grandma an iPad every 5 years for the rest of her life than try to teach her how to use a general-purpose computer, but that’s not a reasonable solution for everyone.
Personally, I’d rather buy my grandma an iPad every 5 years for the rest of her life than try to teach her how to use a general-purpose computer, but that’s not a reasonable solution for everyone.
For example, the Nexus 5 phone released about 8 years ago is still selling for over $100 on eBay because it's easy to install hacking software on it that was featured in Mr. Robot.
If you have an iPhone that old that no longer receives iOS updates, there's no way to get security updates on it or install some other OS.
I think there's more desire and utility the other way around-- old general purpose laptops make pretty good Chromebooks (by using Neverware's Cloudready, no also owned by Google), but there's not much demand for turning eight old Chromebooks into general purpose computers.
I have such an old Chromebook. I bought it for about $130. It has a mediocre keyboard and an 11" lower-quality TN display. Now it doesn't get OS updates.
Current eBay price is $20.
It's a hopeful sign that OP's parents are at least catching on to the planned obsolescence pattern. That makes it easier to explain the importance of right-to-repair type regulations to a non-technical audience.
Contrast that support with Google Chrome, its latest browser works on OS X El Capitan 10.11 from 2015: https://support.google.com/chrome/a/answer/7100626?hl=en - which is much more reasonable.
EDIT: I was wrong. mrpippy pointed out in a reply below that Mojave is still supported by the latest FF release. I was using the FF ESR release which only goes up to FF version 91. Sorry for the noise, and thanks for correcting me.
The hardware itself is supported just fine; install Linux on your 2011 Macbook and you can download the latest and greatest Firefox release. Mozilla just doesn't spend much time on operating systems that have fallen out of support. I don't expect them to keep their Windows 7 builds going for long once Microsoft ends their paid support programme.
If Apple doesn't bother publishing regular security and maintenance updates, then why should Mozilla? Users shouldn't be running operating systems that receive no or only some security patches anyway.
I appreciate that Mozilla has fewer resources than Google, but having the latest version of FireFox working only on macOS versions released within the past two years is unnecessarily restrictive in my opinion. I'm an independent software developer far more financially constrained than Mozilla who supports macOS releases going back 10 years. It's just a matter of not using the new API calls shipped with each new OS release and optionally dynamically loading the API calls that are not present on all OS versions.
EDIT: My original post was wrong. Mozilla still supports Mojave. See details above.
https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/where-find-release-note...
https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/91.5.0/releasenotes/
I just assumed I downloaded the regular Firefox release, but evidently not.
During the in-situ upgrade process, I probably got hit with this installation bug (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MacOS_Big_Sur#Criticism) where the installer never finishes if you have more than 20,000 folders in an obscure folder. I'll never know because I was forced to wipe the disk and perform a clean install. But before you wipe your disk, do a search for "Macintosh HD - Data" and "Macintosh HD - Data - Data", because the Big Sur installer is apparently not idempotent, so you need to delete the "Macintosh HD - Data" volume if the installer breaks halfway through the process.
You should create the USB installer before all this because the clean install may download the Big Sur image, then throw it away, and proceed to download and install Snow Leopard instead. At least that's what happened to me. But Snow Leopard not have the certificates necessary to connect the App Store. So the machine can't download the Big Sur image anymore. The only way around that is to own a second Mac to download the image and create the bootable USB drive for Big Sur, and do another clean install.
So I totally agree
The iPad, while a great machine, can’t really be considered “general-purpose” since I can’t compile and run arbitrary code on it. For most iPad users this is a feature: it makes the thing much safer to use.
Going back to your original comment above, a general purpose computer definitely helps. But as the chromebook side of things shows, it's not sufficient.