Even domestically, that above quote only applies in specific cases - civil cases, or criminal cases where it can be proven evidence was actually destroyed. I'm not personally aware of clear evidence of bad-faith destruction of evidence right now on China's part. China's refusal to allow a third-party investigation would then be more similar to pleading the 5th, something even US courts are prevented from punishing.
Does knowing this help fight it? Does it help stop it? Does it help treat it? Does it help stop the spread?
Let's say China even INTENTIONALLY did it. Then what? You gonna invade China? Exactly how are you gonna make someone like Apple pull out of China when they should already be doing that NOW for other reasons?
I regard the "lab leak hypothesis" like I regard news about celebrities--worthless and unactionable.
It's simply a "boogeyman" to focus hate to create the "in group" and the "out group" for propaganda purposes.
Assuming the best, the parent asked a bunch of questions (in an admittedly dismissive and argumentative way) to try and invite some kind of response that explains what China gets out of it, and what the world does next if we could somehow prove China created the original virus.
So … let’s assume China created it. Now what?
What’s the next step and response if it was an accident?
What’s the next step and response if it was intentional?
Edit: I’m asking because I’m genuinely curious about what the next step would be. I mean, it’d satisfy my curiosity and interest in knowing the cause and origin. But then I want to figure out what the world response should be.
I asked what you thought those options are since you seem to have some opinions. Or at least a few of them. Specifically.
I don’t see how I said anything that indicates I’m trying to fight on the internet about our worldviews.
Great. So you agree that there are other options in between do nothing, and an invasion.
Both you, and everyone else, agrees on that idea. So that means that you personally can think of some in between those two extremes.
One option instead of full scale invasion is to cut back or attach strings to some of those forms of cooperation.
This happens all the time.
In this specific scenario, it might look like: Spend $100M upgrading Wuhan lab security and we won’t indefinitely ban travel from Wuhan Province to the US.
Or, more aggressively: Shut down the Wuhan lab or we will release tons of hacked data about corruption in the government.
Not saying that these are smart options, but you get the idea of the spectrum of options between total absolution and total aggression.
Oh, for sure. Those are certainly the broad categories of foreign policy and cooperative (and coercive) action.
I appreciate the specific ideas. I really am just curious what others’ ideas are on specific actions that could be taken if there was suddenly definitive proof tomorrow of origins.
If (the collective) we just shrugged it off because we didn’t want to offend anyone do you think things would be any different today?
> What’s the next step
Stop trusting sources or information coming out of china, if western sources contradict it. Thats the next step. Update your informational priors, to disregard them. And then also convince other people to disregard them, and make fun of people you know, who uses those sources, if there are contradictory western sources.
Assuming that is true.
Are you asking what China would have done with the result of researching COVID?
Same thing anyone does with research?
Or are you asking what we do with the information as to why something bad happened?
Same things / reasons we want to know why something bad happened?
Another action the world can take is to hold them responsible for actions. This may be in various ways like non co-operation, economic sanctions etc
Q: What would happen if we deliberately did everything possible to artificially create the circumstances leading to a pandemic?
A: A pandemic
Any value of such research SHOULD be questioned.
That said: it doesn’t even need to go that far - whether the response should be punitive, it doesn’t need to be. The scientific communities in China and the west are collaborative and could negotiate agreements not to do GoF research. US groups were funneling money into China to do GoF research on coronaviruses, which could be stopped.
The west, or society, should use this as evidence of basically not trusting information from the government of china, if it is contradicted by more neutral or western sources, in the future.
So, for example, if someone is talking to you personally, and they try to use evidence from that government, and you have other evidence from western sources that contradicts it, you should just laugh in their face. Call them a mean name and ridicule them.
The lab leak was most likely a protocol error and without a collective awareness of the cause, the population cannot push our elected leaders to demand better safety protocols.
If there was an international agreement to stop gain of function research, then that motivation would be gone.
https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2021/10/nih-admits-funding-r...
Your logic is like BP saying “hey it doesn’t matter how the oil spill started . . .”
And how do you plan on enforcing this on China? Or on Russia?
I'm still waiting for all the armchair geniuses to explain this one to me.
You can be ready for when some idiot does this research or not. Those are your options unless you've got some magic way to go to war with nuclear powers that I am unaware of.
All banning gain of function research does is leave you unprepared when it happens.
Unless you've got a way to enforce this on China, this is unactionable. It's simply propaganda to rile people up.
1) If it was an accident, what are you going to do? If there is anyone sane in the leadership of the lab with knowledge of how this occurred, procedures have already changed. What more do you want them to do? You're NOT going to get a gain-of-function ban without some form of strong coercion. What will it be?
2) If it was intentional (and I see no gain for China if it were), what do you plan to do? You will have to somehow do something to cause actual harm to Chinese leadership. What? China is already guilty of genocide, and all the West does is shrug.
Hell, it would almost be better if this were an intentional release if not for all the dead. The emergence of Omicron would demonstrate to the idiots worldwide who thought they could control a virus that the idea is laughable and that the virus will quickly evade whatever you think are your protection measures.
And all this ASSUMES that it actually was a lab leak, which the current hypothesis about jumping from mice back to humans decreases the Bayesian prior on dramatically. If Covid can jump that quickly from humans to mice and back, gain of function is suddenly frighteningly common. And the research into gain of function, rather than being banned, needs to be ramped up hard.
> focus hate
That wouldn't be me.
I would feel bad for the people who caused the leak (edit to be clear: if this is what happened, not assuming anything here). To be at the origin of such a pandemic spanning multiple years with all the repercussions must be uncomfortable.