I'm sorry but this feels wrong. The existing sponsors should have their subscriptions cancelled, instead of going to a new organization automatically.
I'm sorry but this feels wrong. The existing sponsors should have their subscriptions cancelled, instead of going to a new organization automatically.
Any sponsorships tied to marak's personal GitHub account were not changed, of course.
This is also consistent with the original terms:
> During the conversation with Ben, he went over the terms and conditions of the Open Collective with me.
> Ben said that simply, "The funding is attached to the project, not the current maintainer."
Full details: https://github.com/faker-js/faker/discussions/56#discussionc...
Yeah, but the project is not actually the same anymore. The new project taking over the name and URL of the old project doesn't make it "the same" project.
Do you really think the sponsors and the people using this code actually care that one person (of many contributors to the project) who wanted to break the project is no longer part of the project?
It's a technicality, but in practice nobody actually cares. If they wanted to sponsor Marak they would have done it through his Github sponsorships. If they wanted to sponsor Fakerjs, in whatever form it takes, they would choose the Open Collective and their associated terms that allow for exactly this scenario.
Some of them probably do. And some probably don't like the way in which the takeover was done, or don't like the new guys, even if they don't really like what the old guy did either.