> Among those previously infected, until the emergence of the Omicron variant, the cumulative incidence of COVID19 was not significantly different between those vaccinated and unvaccinated, even at almost a year of follow-up.
> However, among those with prior COVID-19, vaccination was not associated with significantly lower risk of COVID-19 in either the pre-Omicron (HR 0.78, 95% C.I. 0.31-1.96) or the Omicron phase (HR 0.77, 95% C.I. 0.53-1.12).
The only thing they find is that there's some effectiveness against symptomatic illness during the Omicron wave:
> among those with prior COVID-19, vaccination was associated with significantly lower risk of symptomatic COVID-19 in both the pre-Omicron (HR 0.60, 95% C.I. 0.40-0.90) and the Omicron phase (HR 0.36, 95% C.I. 0.23-0.57).
Apparently this is based on the data in Figure 4...but Figure 4 isn't included (again, did you read this??), so I can't say either way.
> I don't want to go around checking if people had or did not have Covid, which a lot of people are prone to lying about.
We're not talking about sterilizing immunity. Even the best case arguments for booster doses in the young are citing efficacy against "symptomatic illness" that is well below 100%.
Case in point: I just had it. I'm triple vaccinated. I'm not alone.
Why?
1) I am of an age where risk/reward ratio is clearer. It still isn't so compelling that I rushed to do it, but far better than for college kids.
2) I was (and remain) concerned that the dark-blue city where I live is going to mandate them to participate in normal life. I find this loathsome, but I am not in a position to fight it.
3) It gives me a certain authority when I tell people that I don't believe in vaccine mandates or many of our policies, yet I am 100% compliant with the rules.
4) I thought maybe it would keep me from catching a cold.
Alas, because the universe tends toward maximum irony, a week after the booster I caught Omicron.
[0] https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2787447?gu...
Because it’s difficult to verify. “Oh, I had it last year” would become the new “the ADA says you can’t make me wear a mask” thing.
Of course they are taking it into account.
Most health authorities do random sampling to try to get an idea of underlying natural immunity and the various characteristics that takes on.
FYI The reason we're not going to accept 'natural immunity' as a legit form of documented immunity is because millions of idiots will go and get COVID on purpose , as they'd prefer getting it 'the natural way' as opposed to getting a jab.
This is the difference between 'Science' and 'Public Health Policy'.
I just had an anti-vaxx colleague do exactly that, and it wasn't even for some kind of immune benefit, rather, 'just to get it over with'. I was completely floored when she told me.
But I'm now convinced that my anti-vaxx cousins who are now barred from the liquor stores, would get COVID 'on purpose' if they could get their passport to alcohol and not have to get the 'Goddam Fauci Jab'.