WTF Happened to the BMJ?
respectfulinsolence.com
respectfulinsolence.com
I had wondered. The first I heard about this was on HN, when the BMJ was complaining about being fact-checked on Facebook. Reading their article, it was clear that they were defending a dubious set of charges that seemed out of keeping with their place as a foremost medical journal. Not a lie, exactly, but something clearly designed to magnify small issues as bigger than they were, and ignore the ways that experimental design deals with issues like those.
It smelled odd. I'd been tempted to say that Facebook should probably defer to top-tier journals even when they're not doing their best work. Even when that not-best-work is being used to cause such harm -- it was obvious that even the worst interpretation of the incident didn't invalidate the fact that the vaccine was safe and effective, and obvious that people would use the article to say the obvious.
But if BMJ has hired people with a pseudoscience agenda... I'm really not sure what to do. I have to rely on experts outside of my domain, and I have to rely on a web of reputation to find those experts.