Just my two cents.
Just my two cents.
Your last sentence seems to be describing a DRM problem which, AFAIK, is an entirely different class of problem.
Fine Art is about story and provenance. NFTs do provide both.
In his article on Web3, Moxie Marlinspike wrote this:
> So as an experiment, I made an NFT that changes based on who is looking at it, since the web server that serves the image can choose to serve different images based on the IP or User Agent of the requester. For example, it looked one way on OpenSea, another way on Rarible, but when you buy it and view it from your crypto wallet, it will always display as a large [poop] emoji. What you bid on isn’t what you get. There’s nothing unusual about this NFT, it’s how the NFT specifications are built. Many of the highest priced NFTs could turn into [poop] emoji at any time; I just made it explicit.
User david_ar had this great comment about IPFS and permanence:
> You shouldn't read "permanent" as "eternal", but as "not temporary" --- in the same sense as "permanent address" or "permanent employment". HTTP is temporary in the sense that you're relying on a single server to actively continue serving a file for it to remain available. IPFS is permanent in the sense that, so long as the file exists somewhere in the network, it will remain available to everyone.
> Edit: If you want to ensure your content remains available, you still need to host it somewhere (your own server, convincing/paying someone else to, etc). IPFS isn't so much about storage as it is about distribution.
IPFS ensures the file won't change but says nothing about availability.
As to permanence, IPFS makes it easy to pin any available data on your own node to ensure it stays around. Even if it disappears from the network for a time it can be re-added with the same content ID as long as someone retains a copy. Just make sure you save it somewhere, preferably before spending money on the NFT. If the file completely disappears your NFT won't be worth much.
An IPFS url is a commitment to a file. It’s only the commitment that’s important really.
Fine art is about being aesthetically pleasing. A JPG can do this on its own, without an NFT.
Maybe you mean the value of art is determined by, among other things, story and provenance? Sure, NFTs provide those two. What they don’t provide, which in my opinion is the most important part, is a unique piece of art. Some think a unique record in a blockchain that points to a non-unique copy of a JPG is equivalent, but it is not.
“Nothing”. Except, that we can prove Leonardo painted it as we have the history of ownership. The fact the jpeg isn’t unique isn’t the problem. It’s who minted the NFT. If you know it’s the artist, then only that “copy” is the real one. It’s all bullshit I know but there is an approximation of the above question.