The latter uses markets as a stand in for morality. When bad outcomes occur, it definitionally cannot be due to the market, but some other bad actors.
Also, markets can't allow innovations from the ground up by themselves, the require a government to implement a fragile and inefficient intellectual property system, but that's just nitpicking.
Of course people don't have to face literal starvation to be under control, but the system fundamentally requires that the level of deprivation always be enough to meet the requirement of keeping labor under control.
No true free market would [ insert as appropriate ].
Unions? Monopoly power? Government enforcing contracts? Government competing in the market? Natural disasters? Normal weather? Taxation? No taxation? Strong property rights? No property rights?
A "perfectly free market" is a meaningless phrase dressed up to sound like "frictionless in a vacuum". It exists for the purposes of cynical lobbying.
In this case the market is up against (arguably irrational) water rights and such, the market is far from free.
> The planning and management of water in California is subject to a vast number of laws, regulations, management plans, and historic water rights. The state agency responsible for water planning is the California Department of Water Resources.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_in_California#Planning_a...
The water example is pretty bad, given that we don't charge the actual price of water to subsidize businesses. If we'd charge the real price (and ideally tax negative externalities) much farming would likely leave California.
Because those who succeed in a market end up with the money to influence policy. That is why that is important. Policy affects markets which then affects policies. It is a concept in capitalism we are not going to get away from.
What does preferential treatment by the government have to do with the market? If the farmers didn't get water at a heavily discounted price from the government, they likely wouldn't be able to grow such water intensive crops and the crops would be grown in places that were not contained on the resource. Heck, they even grow rice in CA!
Throughout all recorded history those who have been well connected with those in power have unfairly benefited from that. This isn't something that only came about in modern times. It is only in modern political systems with rule of law, property rights, recognition of inalienable rights, etc. where people feel that this kind of political favoritism is bad and work to limit it by constraining the power of those in power. Constraining the the rulers is done by limiting their power by written constitutions, political transparency, etc. One can certainly argue (and I would agree) that there is more political favoritism than there should be, but at least modern economic systems think it is a bad thing and people work to limit it.
Edit: Also, a market with redistribution is more democratic. More actors have money to provide market input (demand or investment) when resources are not highly concentrated.
Also, even in the labor market, the scenario you're describing is punishing the labor buyer but rewarding the labor provider, so it's not just the capital market that's less free, it's the labor market too.
More actors being able to provide input is restricting the markets. The market allocated who gets to provide input in itself.
All I'm saying is, don't fetishize the market being free.
Even in the tech industry this is true. People were shocked the other day when they found out that their income data was being reported and sold by the big credit companies in America. Google, Microsoft, Amazon, they all share their employees income data with one another through 3rd parties. They have so much more knowledge than you or I and it represents a huge advantage for them when hiring.
UBI does not generate competition. It's a supplement. All it does is translate the supply curve rightwards. While UBI might stimulate demand in the short term, it doesn't fundamentally change the relationship. The eventual outcome of sustained UBI is an inflationary spiral.
- - - -
To me, the unspoken and often unconscious nature of the "stick" of vagrancy and homelessness is revealed clearly when people ask, "But who will pick up the garbage?" when you're talking about things like a "post-scarcity" or "abundance-based" society. The clear implication is that without the hell of homelessness there are needful jobs that we couldn't otherwise force people to do.