Selective bias.. ugh.. why are you beating yourself up. All else equal, objective, analytical, and focused approach to a problem is going to generate better results.
Unless the problem involves people, in which case a healthy dose of the right emotions and some subjectivity can help the process along.
And behind every technical problem there is always a people problem.
People are data points awaiting anticipated reciprocity. Knowing that is the difference between empathy and sympathy.
yikes
I don't think its a matter of humility being valued for its own sake, but that behavior describable by the antonyms of humility are commonly perceived as correlating with poor judgement and a tendency to substitute their goals for those of the project.