> My mom worked for a GP for about 20 years, and it seemed to me that most of what made that guy a doctor was bedside manner + being able to remember a lot of things.
That’s exactly right, but there’s nothing wrong with that.
A good doctor’s memory of patients spanning decades of a career and all of the various treatments that they did or did not respond to is very valuable. It’s a good thing that they offload as much as possible to other people so they can focus on doing what they do best.