A good folder hierarchy is like a library: you know where it is even before you look for it.
I'd rather not rely on my own willingness to organize files so I'll take a search tool any day.
This becomes more important as you get older and begin to experience the pleasures of reading things again for the “first” time.
I admit I sometimes search for files, but it's a filename search, not a content search. I don't want a background service indexing the files and contents of all my disks when I can use a regular search instead.