First: are we talking past each others? You seem reasonable but some of the things doesn't make sense to me which often indicates a misunderstanding on one of the sides :-)
If not, here are some clarifications. (Maybe they'll help even if we are talking past each other.)
> Removing can't always be done later, because that requires rewriting the repository's history.
I knew this could come up which is why I included glossed over.
> Logical commits serve a real purpose: they make change review easier and can help bisect bugs later.
Nothing I wrote was meant to conflict with that. Quite on the contrary I specifically want more points to bisect against (yes, I'm one of those who actually uses bisect).
> If thought process is important, it should be captured in a structured way like a thoughtful commit message or README addition. Not some cobbled together mess of whatever commits someone made haphazardly.
Have you tried getting anything reasonable about the thought process behind a feature into a README, and then tried to get it to stick there?
On the other hand a bunchbof commits along the lines of:
- rough first sketch
- introduce tests.
Also includes modifications to xyz to simplify testing.
- performance optimizations
- more tests
- Introduce test for foo and fix it in bar and baz
This has a negative impact on performance but is hard to avoid.
etc