It’s such (excuse my language) bullshit. The facility is incredibly safe. It would be so much safer than leaving spent nuclear fuel on site all across the country. It’s unbelievable that there is resistance to it.
It’s such (excuse my language) bullshit. The facility is incredibly safe. It would be so much safer than leaving spent nuclear fuel on site all across the country. It’s unbelievable that there is resistance to it.
The perception of nuclear waste seems to be that it will melt your hand off if you touch it for the next 10,000 years but the reality is that the things that are that radioactive don't have that long of a half life. The waste, which has a much longer half life, is, by definition, much less radioactive. The longer it takes to decay, the less radioactive it is. I think this is a very big factor is the public perception of nuclear waste disposal.
I found this[1] article that has a pretty solid breakdown of it.
[1] https://www.kitco.com/commentaries/2021-11-30/Key-facts-abou...
With regards to them being "incredibly safe", how do we know? There are countless examples of chemical waste sites around the country which were promised to be leak proof and safe, but the chemical industry was totally lying. Many of those sites are leaching poisons and carcinogens into the environment and we are spending billions of dollars to clean up those super fund sites, and will be spending billions of dollars into the foreseeable future. Does the nuclear industry have more credibility than the chemical industry? I don't trust people who are so sure of themselves when they forecast 100's or 1000's of years into the future.
Lastly, it's not clear to me that spreading nuclear fuel across multiples sites across the country is actually less safe. It does increase the chance of something going wrong among all those sites, but the impact of one of those incidents will be far smaller than concentrating all the spent fuel in one place. After all, it's the concentration of nuclear material that makes them dangerous, since all that material originally came from various mines on earth.
Spent fuel is a lot hotter than what came out of mines on earth-- for a few decades.
All the other waste isn't very concentrated in absolute terms, but putting it in one place can make sense.
Though I seem to have a strong distrust for "experts" in certain fields, such as the petroleum industry, the chemical industry, and the nuclear industry. These are industries which tend to privatize the profits and socialize the costs, so I don't trust these "experts" to prioritize the welfare of the general public.
The thing that's particularly annoying is you don't want to get groundwater leeching stuff, and you need to keep cooling fans running for sure so that the fuel doesn't get hot and smoke. After that, it's a pretty boring pile of heavy metal waste.
> These are industries which tend to privatize the profits and socialize the costs,
Note that fairly generous costs for disposal have been collected from the whole industry. There's just a question of how we actually spend them to dispose stuff.
I'm not sure I trust that they calculated the cost of disposal properly. Because if the disposal cost was more than the revenue generated by the nuclear industry, the entire industry would have become unprofitable. The lobbyists and politicians would never have allowed the regulators to collect enough. Hence socializing the cost.
On the other hand, if we find that we aren't de-carbonizing fast enough, and the cost of global warming is far higher than the harm caused by the nuclear industry, then I think we have no choice but to increase our nuclear energy production. But I have serious doubts that our political system, our current political climate, and regulatory capture in the nuclear industry will allow that policy decision to be made in a competent manner. It's a conundrum.
I don't believe that's the case, looking at the actual reserves... and looking at the overall regulatory climate for nuclear. NRC has been a pretty strict regulator that hasn't been very hesitant to apply uneconomic costs to nuclear operators, which is part of why nuclear is so expensive. Indeed, nuclear has been structurally unprofitable in the face of very cheap natural gas from fracking, which is one reason why you don't see operators lining up to spend capital to open nuclear plants.
Compare to fossil fuel plants: 100% of the harms are socialized (national security, health effects from particulates, global warming, etc). Here, you're asserting without evidence that the cost of waste disposal may have been underestimated.
The CSB has only been around since like 1998 vs the much older NRC. The NRC is also much more safety oriented. There's only been 1 civilian nuclear death in the US and it was in 1964. The nuclear navy has never had a serious incident. I think in total there have been 7 total civilian nuclear incidents in the US, ever, and most have been minor, hurt no one, and were a long time ago.
> After all, it's the concentration of nuclear material that makes them dangerous
That's not exactly true. Exposure to high does of ionizing radiation makes it dangerous. That can be mitigated by securing material, which can be done by keeping it in one place. The NRC is very much in favor of long term storage solutions, as are all nuclear safety experts. Most favor deep underground salt formations vs. the Nevada site though.
I'm not sure why the approach of giving the state piles of money in exchange for hosting the storage wasn't tried initially. Or maybe it was, but was downplayed enough that it never comes up. Nevada isn't a very populous state so billions of extra dollars would go pretty far. It has also been trying to diversify its economy for a while now, with pretty mediocre results.
That's such a ridiculous claim.
One hundred thousand years, mate.
Absolutely ridiculous!
If the opposing party managed to force them, their candidates would get creamed (in Nevada) up and down the ballot. Right up to the top.
That's democracy. You get votes by trading your top issues for other people's. It tends to settle into parties to formalize the arrangements.
No, we have parties because some issues are partisan. If every issue was partisan, then "partisan" wouldn't have any meaning. Trivial counter proof: the PATRIOT Acts was a bipartisan issue.
> Nevada doesn't want it and enlists their allies for support. It so happens that they are Democrats, and it's true that there is an anti nuclear wing of the Democratic party, but that's not really the issue here. They don't want to be forced to take nuclear waste and their allies support them.
You referenced a 50/50 split in congress as an obstacle as though one party is opposes nuclear and one party favors it. I don't think that's the case--I think there's strong anti-nuclear representation on both sides.
> That's democracy. You get votes by trading your top issues for other people's. It tends to settle into parties to formalize the arrangements.
Right, but that doesn't imply that nuclear is a partisan issue, contra your claims.
I'm not sure what's going on with that now. Apparently the Democrats still oppose it. As do many Republicans, who didn't force it through when they had the chance.
As I said, it's not so much about pro vs anti nuclear but specifically about Yucca Mountain. Even pro nuclear people don't necessarily want to build there specifically. The 50-50 split means that it takes unanimity to get anything done, and neither party has it. (It takes more than unanimity, in fact, but usually much more to get past the filibuster.)
Perhaps it causes a positive bias in the natural selection or is the side effect of something that causes a positive bias?