The letter that started AMD's Open-Source Strategy
phoronix.com
phoronix.com
Just like any other organization the FOSS community has a reputation. If we desire action, we need to cultivate a positive one. A track record of successful opening abd development of closed source would really help cracking some of the other closed-source nuts.
"Slower" really depends on what you're doing. If you're doing lots of 2D stuff, then no, not by a long shot; the open drivers are generally very speedy for 2D stuff. If you're doing 3D stuff, then the raw framerates might be slower for games, but as a general rule, nobody's paid to make open drivers as fast as possible, only fast enough to run well.
There's also a bit of disconnect between blessed AMD drivers and OEM drivers for Windows; there's known hardware which has never been supported by the AMD Windows drivers but works fine in Linux under the open driver stack. "Later" is kind of a loaded term; if you buy an AGP HD 2400 with a PCIe-to-AGP bridge, it has immediate Windows support, from the OEM, but with no updates and no upgrade path. Linux support lagged for that chipset by about four-six months but continues today, with updates and fixes.
So, tl;dr: It varies so much that this question ends up being loaded.
I've had nVidia cards in the past and they have worked much better on a multi-monitor environment than my current ATI ones.