People advocate for understood constraints of critical infrastructure. Engineers usually have knowledge about longevity and reliability of components.
There are examples of man-made systems which absolutely require 100% reliability, but those still have lifetimes and will be destroyed at some point to be replaced with something else[0].
A bridge can be destroyed, but it should not collapse without prior warning.
I am. People need to understand that bridges continue to exist when they're not looking at them.
I don't even know if you can achieve 100% reliability given a set of plausible situations/usage, because you'd have to imagine every single possible failure mode for the thing that you're building.
That is - the threat of "destruction" proper (which you contrasted with "collapse without prior warning") is included in the reliability metrics for a device.
The point stands. Nothing that humans build can be 100% reliable - the only thing you can do is asymptotically approach it.
Now, that said - three nines per year is way too low for me, personally. Five nines is more comfortable (and if it's cheap I'd like to go higher).
So you are ok if in a city with 100 bridges there is an average of one collapse every 10 years?
I mean, technically, one would need to look at the reliability-cost curve. opwieurposiu would almost certainly be fine with eight 9's of reliability if it only cost twice as much as three 9's. The fact that they have a really high risk tolerance in this area don't really undermine their general point.
Ill stick to our current failure rate, thank you. IT “reliability” rates isn't that impressive in other fields of engineering.
Nobody is saying that a bridge should last forever. They're saying repair it as long as you can, then replace the bridge so that a collapse never happens.
Nobody is advocating that "the perfect bridge" be built. They are advocating that already built bridges receive regular maintenance.
Expecting that a bridge doesn't collapse is an entirely achievable goal. Expecting that a bridge doesn't collapse without maintenance is very unlikely.