And all of the connotations that people associate with PCs eg. unreliability, viruses, malware, constant updates and complexity are not something that people are in a hurry to bring across to the mobile world.
Then again we can look to the market for guidance which is that side loading has in no way impacted the success of iOS devices.
Problems from the early 2000s that don't exist in the same capacity anymore. In fact, I would say getting scammed by an app from the apple app store is more likely than downloading a virus in 2022.
> constant updates
That's a mobile problem.
And you would be wrong.
With viruses, at least the OS vendors are getting rid of them.
Nonsense. I've cleaned malware off of employee laptops within the last 2 years. And off family members' computers within the last 3 months.
So this malware that you had to clean off of those laptops would still not be possible, even for sideloaded apps.
This Christmas I had to uninstall adware from my Grandmothers phone that was filling the notification bar with ads.
Last time I visited my other grandparents I had to warn my grandmother not to click on an offer to install device drivers, that had somehow shown up as an add in a Microsoft Game.
And language such as "side loading" helps that too.
Perhaps you're just scoping it to the mobile tables and phones, those are indeed locked down but I don't mind it, they are appliances to me and I want the manufacturer to be 100% responsible for it, 100% of the time.
The right I am talking about is primarily the right of exclusion and its not just an American concept plenty of other countries have similar concepts or even the same name, but of course the exact details will vary from one legal system to an other.
Effectively apple retains the right of exclusion via extralegal means by using cryptography. Apple can unilaterally decide to exclude software from devices they don't own by not signing it. If you wrote some software yourself for instance you would also still have to ask apple to sign it which they only will do under certain conditions. Essentially if you have to keep having to ask a 3rd party to do something with something you “own” you don’t fully own it.
Why it’s extralegal is that normally a seller would require a buyer to agree to a contract to retain some rights over real or tangible property. Instead apple is using cryptography to effectively retain some property rights despite the buyer never signing a contract agree-ing to this arrangement.
You agree to the terms when you first use the device.
And if you don’t agree to the terms you can get a refund and buy another phone.
The problem still persists that apple is selling hardware that you don’t have full control over. What if I wanted to run linux instead or even bare metal code that I wrote myself? Apple does not permit this nor will sign such software so that boot-rom will load it to RAM. Just because your average user may not do those things does not mean their rights are not being effectively diminished compared to other tangible property they buy.
Apple is under no obligation however to compromise the security of their device in order to help you.
This technically is ridiculous and completely untrue.
Web applications, by design, have a tiny fraction of the capabilities of a fully fledged mobile app.
[0] https://jonbottarini.com/2021/12/09/dont-reply-a-clever-phis...
[1] https://www.theverge.com/2022/1/16/22886809/safari-15-bug-le...
[2] https://nvd.nist.gov/vuln/detail/CVE-2021-30858
[3] https://www.ryanpickren.com/safari-uxss
Also your not free to install any software on the device unless your lucky enough to find an exploit.
Is that a fact? I think not. (don't misunderstand me, I would love mobile hardware to be 'the same' as fixed PCs, but as far as the world is concerned, it is not.)
If you think: phone has CPU, memory and storage, thus it is a computer and I need to have the same "access" as a 1990's PC, then yes, the whole world might as well be burning right now. But if you take it for the appliance that it is, are you really surprised it works the way it does?
If you are so worried about 'rights', where do you draw the line? (pun incoming) your modem, CMTS/CPE/ODN are all closed, crypto-sealed and inseparable hardware+software as well, as is the core router your packets flow through, the TCON board in your flat screen monitor and the microcontroller in your USB charger. Get a CPU from Intel, AMD, Qualcomm, TI, Nvidia, MediaTek, Rockchip etc., get a sealed boot loader that is cryptographically tied to the chip and the chip manufacturer. Heck, to get that sealed stuff as an ODM you sign so many NDAs it might as well be an appliance in itself.
The days that you bought some end-user high-level hardware and had control over the stack are gone. Not because it can't be done differently, but because it's not viable. Even framework is having a hard time (as are Purism and System76) getting any true 'open' system. Not even a libreboot/coreboot system is actually unencumbered if you use any hardware from the last 5 years. People want a whole bunch of things, but the scale simply isn't there to carry the cost.
Ironically, all of this stems from lawyering from the corporate side.
You cannot install a working Wireguard on macOS outside of the App Store.
They don't want you to think of them as (general-purpose) computers.
Also just take the name AMD it stands for advance micro devices.
What's the one and only thing that a smart phone or tablet is meant to do? If it's make phone calls, most people don't anymore and doesn't apply to tablets.
This is an absurd argument.
I have an app that I wrote myself and run just on “my own” iDevices that I have to re-install every week because the installation certificate expires. I'd have to pay the annual $99 tax just for the privilege of running my own frigging software on “my” iDevices without hassle.