If it is not the most profitable, why wouldn't we expect it to lose money over time to competing algorithms?
The only way I could see this working is if the exchange deliberately gave the AMM some kind of advantage, like allowing it to trade much faster than all other participants, or without paying fees. Say, if it were allowed to connect to an exchange like IEX in front of the fiber optic speedbump.
However, it's efficient when it comes to computational power (and cost!) required. On Ethereum, storing a megabyte of data costs hundreds of thousands of dollars.
These are expensive things to maintain.
Whereas with AMMs and liquidity pool assets, the community can provide liquidity, have a passive income stream, build new markets for the liquidity pool shares, and have routing between different asset’s liquidity pools such that the base currency isnt as important.
I like limit orders, especially for accumulation at the same price, but with the advent of this method I see more benefits. AMMs with ranged liquidity fulfills what I like about limit orders too.
I agree with idea/interesting concept of making market making better investible, tough.
(I’m sure people will try to abuse that to warp liquidity, but they already can by unwinding and removing their share.)
Range liquidity and liquidity pool optimizers reduce, eliminate, or make it profitable despite IL, even in volatile environments
All I’m seeing is that tradfi capital markets would benefit more and more
Arguably, some dark pools also are like this with clear execution rules and an outside price oracle - only up to a point comparable, though.
By EMH there's no such thing as free lunch or true passive income. This is especially true in trading. Profit-seeking activities with low barrier-of-entry eventually become races to the bottom. If there's easy money to be made with passive AMM, people will jump into it en masse and eventually compete on cost-saving. Much like mining, where electricity costs and how quickly you can fix mining rigs with few resources could make and break a farm.
If, for example, credit risk on a bond changes the formulaic nature of an AMM will open up huge arbitrage opportunities.
Somehow price discovery is usually ignored in AMM circles, markets are not just about liquidity provision.
Market making can lose a ton if money quickly, and right now those losses would flow heavily into predictable AMMs if they were around in traditional asset classes.