Just about every debate about ‘censorship’ I’ve encountered ends up with people debating the meaning of the word itself. And, there is a sizable contingent of people asserting only the government can censor. It’s already too late.
I'm old enough to remember when the only things that weren't censored were the racist and sexist bits.
Now, a ridiculous number [1] of Americans support censorship. We have surveys showing most college kids want to ban “hate speech” and heterodoxy [2] (big problem- who gets to define “hate”?).
The ACLU is backing away from defending free speech; here’s a former director of the ACLU [3].
Journalists now regularly host intelligence community propagandists [4] and support “fact checking” and government mandated bans on “misinformation” [5]. Again, who decides? And not just who decides what the facts are, but who decides what facts to check? Who decides what is “misinformation“ and what are the consequences if the holders of this power are shown to have misjudged?
[1] https://jonathanturley.org/2021/08/20/the-new-censors-polls-...
[2] https://thompsoncenter.wisc.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/509...
[3] https://nypost.com/2022/01/31/ex-aclu-head-ira-glasser-slams...
[4] https://dailycaller.com/2019/08/23/cnn-msnbc-15-spooks-mccab...
[5] https://misinforeview.hks.harvard.edu/article/misinformation... and https://www.thecrimson.com/article/2021/11/9/journalists-iop...
That's definitely not the case in the UK however. And literally never was. The UK has a law banning "obscene publications". It has strong libel laws. It has a broadcasting regulator who can tell the BBC or any other broadcaster (including cable ones) what to do. There is no change to the status quo here.
The ACLU has gone to shit, but that's because all institutions go to shit.
> Journalists now regularly host intelligence community propagandists
I hate to sound like a broken record, but "now"? I just don't know what media you watched that didn't do this. Maybe pick up a used copy of any Bagdikian from the 80s/90s? Or Project Censored?
I feel like young people who grew up on the internet, saying whatever the fuck they wanted because the tendrils of capital and the state hadn't figured out how to stop them yet, have no awareness of the very recent past. And it somehow turned them all into John Birchers.
The reason corporations are woke now is because right-wingers, centrists and apolitical pseudo-libertarians are going to vote in their interests no matter what happens. The only people who potentially oppose them are also woke, so the effective thing is to focus on getting as many of them as possible to ignore everything but racism/sexism/homophobia, which profits couldn't give half a shit about, instead of focusing on our kleptocracy, which is a necessity for profits.
I understand that the situation is oppressive, and violates your sense of justice and your basic ideals of an open society. Society has never been a spherical cow, it's been a production system sitting on the backs of women, minorities, and wage laborers. If you only notice the suppression of speech when it's largely aimed at scientific racism, men's rights activists, and people fighting for the right to spread disease, that says something about you: maybe not that you're a bad person, but that you're a young person, or a sheltered person, or that you've been inattentive to the world until it encroached on your ability to complain about affirmative action or accuse China of being an ancient evil enemy trying to kill us all.
Other people are trying to pay their rent and eat. You might have trouble trying to pay your rent and eat. But if so, name a single thing that woke fascism is keeping you from saying that's materially important to your life?
All I can say is: First they came for the Palestinians... then they continued to come for the Palestinians while white dudes were protesting for the right to say that women naturally hate math.
The shift is clearly more of one from ideas that certain groups consider to be of no value ("vulgarity") to stuff which they consider to be at least relatively valuable "the treatment of casual racism as completely normal behaviour which shouldn't provoke any reaction and might actually be funny, because that's just how things were in the good old days".
The type of edits engaged in have not changed at all, merely the subject matter, which has always had an ideas and politics and offence-based dimension but now takes a somewhat less conservative stance on what is and isn't appropriate. Arguing a threshold has been crossed because casual racism has replaced other things like homosexuality or mocking royalty on the long list of reasons the BBC might deem a sequence inappropriate for broadcast in certain contexts isn't a principled preference for freedom of artistic expression or the circulation of political ideas, it's a culture warrior's opposition to antiracism specifically .
One minor nit: the Sinn Fein revoicing was done by the BBC, but not for that reason. The government had required them not to broadcast SF and IRA 'propaganda' and the revoicing was a way to get around that ban. Thatcher was, apparently, livid.
The Family Shakespeare publication shows that was the case back in the 1800. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Bowdler
> What the hell went wrong with the western world
This, to my reading, implies that there was a time when things were "right" in the western world. And, at some point, something went wrong.