"The results can't be replicated" is different from "the logic here is wrong". So different that this article starts from an entirely invalid premise.
"The results can't be replicated" is different from "the logic here is wrong". So different that this article starts from an entirely invalid premise.
> More seriously, it’s reasonably well-known among mathematicians that published math papers are full of errors.[1]
I think the author's point is that actually the distinction is less clear: many math papers can't be (easily) replicated, yet people in math aren't too worried.
There isn't even so much a notion of "results", just "logically, Y follows from X". If that's wrong, you don't need to run the experiment again (there is no experiment to run), the logic is just flawed.
While it's possible a mistake won't be found, it's a much different problem than running empirical experiments and getting different results.
It’s obviously quantitatively different in very important and meaningful ways, but the author I think is drawing an apt analogy.