I don't see how the conclusion follows from the premise.
It doesn't seem appropriate to assume that politicians are acting in good faith dialectical fashion, based on literally every observation we've ever made of their actions vs their rhetoric.
Recall the HN community going apeshit over Apple’s proposed methodology to address this issue. That solution was engineered to benefit Apple and was imperfect, but fundamentally addressed CSAM risk with a proven methodology and preserved strong crypto.
That visceral, apeshit reaction was incited by a poorly written EFF article that blurred the lines between a parental control and CSAM.
So yay, we won. Now broken encryption is back and may well pass, as both law and order moderates and batshit crazy conservatives can find common ground.
[0] https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/21194217-earn_it_act...
https://www.wyden.senate.gov/news/press-releases/wyden-on-re...
On any particular issue where Wyden goes against his Democratic party leadership AND Paul goes against his Republican party leadership to agree with each other, that's likely to be an issue where I agree with both of them. Too bad there's no way to vote for a 'virtual politician' that's the logic-gate intersection of those two.
Now this is an intriguing idea.
> MYTH: Requiring companies to be on the lookout for child abuse will harm startups and nascent businesses.
>FACT: No other type of business in the country is provided such blanket and unqualified immunity for sexual crimes against children.
This jumped out out to me in particular. I can think of another similar industry that delivers private packets which may contain CSAM. What is the US Post office doing to evaluate the bits they deliver? What is the post man's legal liability?
That doesn't follow. The worst laws passed (e.g. the Patriot Act) tend to have bipartisan support.
Both parties have pretty wide dumb/authoritarian streaks, so it's not necessarily true that there are legitimate arguments in favor. The war on drugs, for example, had/has bipartisan support even though it is an ongoing demonstrable harm to society.
The “pros” are fairly straightforward, mass data collection makes it easier for law enforcement to do their jobs, or, at least, that’s their opinion.
The safety of our children™!