So, I'll also break it and say thank you for inspiring me to wonder about this.
So, I'll also break it and say thank you for inspiring me to wonder about this.
If this website had private responses, that'd solve that issue, but it'd also make abusive behaviour easier. Then you'd need to have a report system that allowed people to provide context, and before you know it, you need a large moderation team rather than the very small one that Hacker News currently gets away with.
I wonder whether there's a way to have it both ways.
For example, as a user on HN, I've often felt so lost in having conversations longer than a day, because I only notice upticks in my karma (is that what it's called here?) number and if someone replied to something not on the first page of my threads, then it may as well disappear. So I've wondered why HN doesn't have notifications, yet maybe there's a hidden moderation pain that I'm not imagining behind the scenes.
Looking at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, I don't actually see any restrictions on saying nice things. Knock yourself out! It's only if you're criticizing that you have to give yourself a high bar.
It's true that a lot of praise would get tiresome. But that's never a problem in practice. I usually have a clear field any time I want to send someone a compliment.