* how many are functional+orbiting
* how many are nonfunctional+orbiting (i.e. space junk)
* how many are nonfunctional+deorbit(ing|ed)
* how many are functional+orbiting
* how many are nonfunctional+orbiting (i.e. space junk)
* how many are nonfunctional+deorbit(ing|ed)
1. The storm caused the atmosphere to expand
2. which increases drag on satellites.
3. The satellites were in safe mode because of the storm, so…
4. some satellites fell out of orbit because they couldn’t produce enough thrust to recover after the storm
No satellite was ever even at risk of becoming space junk. This is pretty read TFA stuff.
Several governments have space-object tracking systems that work on stuff far smaller than starlink satellites - the US, the EU, Russia, probably China. I doubt that’s open enough for you, though.
Frankly it doesn’t seem to me like there much to hold spacex accountable for. They’re out ~$35mm, but it’s harmless to the rest of us.
> Several governments have space-object tracking systems that work on stuff far smaller than starlink satellites - the US, the EU, Russia, probably China. I doubt that’s open enough for you, though.
I think it’s entirely reasonable to ask for data to back up SpaceX’s assertions and to feel concerned about it not being furnished. This is how proper science and engineering works. We don’t merely take press releases at face value.
You can get the data via several public websites. Here for example are the current orbital elements of all starlink sats in JSON format:
https://celestrak.com/NORAD/elements/gp.php?GROUP=starlink&F...
This is raw data. If you want somebody that processes this data into easily digestable graphs, that also exists.
Follow Jonathan McDowell ( @planet4589 ) on twitter, or read one of these Nasaspaceflight threads:
https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=49936.200 https://forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=50307.0
It is not even that hard to display it yourself. Propagation libraries for most major language exist. Here is a display of all active sats, using wasm and rust that I did as a toy: https://rklaehn.ddns.net/allsats/