People were clicking on his Adwords ads (which would have to be properly descriptive - due to Google's policies) out of choice and were then browsing the guy's site before some of them were clicking on Adsense ads (again, properly described and out of choice).
If someone didn't like the sound of an ad, why would they click on it? They were clicking on the ads, and short of being forced at gunpoint, they obviously "wanted" to click on them.
This site was exploiting a difference between google's advertising cost and its advertising payout. They would buy ads to drive traffic to more ads, and make money on the difference. That's all. The site itself didn't matter, it was all about ads. Google, to their credit, discovered that they weren't making a profit from this customer, so they adjusted their prices accordingly.
And? If you go to work and get paid $50,000, your employer is "exploiting" the difference between the value of your work and what they pay you. That's not a bad thing. An employer adds a lot of value (a team, equipment, various capital expenses) a typically employee could not use on their own.
So it goes with this guy's site. He might have been exploiting a difference, but he was also adding value. If he were not, then the advertisers of the ads he was making money on would have been advertising where /he/ was advertising.
Arbitrage is not in itself bad or deplorable. People seem to have a personal vendetta against it on the Internet, however, due to their undeserved phobia of advertising - an industry that has pretty much fueled our economy (and the Internet generally) for a good 50 years now.
No, but it is annoying because it ends up producing lots of junk on the internet that doesn't really contribute to people finding the information they want - it actually puts another layer in the middle in many cases. I have no problem with advertising, when combined with something of actual interest or value.
> If he were not, then the advertisers of the ads he was making money on would have been advertising where /he/ was advertising.
Or he was just exploiting a temporary hole in the market, in which case, good for him, but he has no right to complain about getting shut down by the same market.
oh my gravy, i have to stop.... i'm so excited and typing so fast I can barely breath
If his site had no "value" then how was it creating $155k/mo of profit? Out of thin air? By browsers forced at gunpoint to click on ads? It had value.
http://timepieces.sourcetool.com/index.php?s=0&l=2&c...
Looks like a spam directory to me.
When I ran a site that had adwords I hated directories like this they would fill up all the ads on my site and no one would click them nor would anyone be happy if they did. It was a constant battle of banning those domains from ads I would allow on my site.
Why not? Google does something similar itself with its "link units" where you click through to a new page with a whole group of ads.
Advertising is not immoral (usually), illegal (usually), or some sort of thing to wipe out. Buying cheap and selling high is how the world works - whether you're selling labor, bricks, commodities, or, yes, advertising.
Would you be raising similar objections if, say, the Yellow Pages advertised with "Find all Builders in YourTown, FL", and it then went to a page with a (paid) list of all the builders in said town? If so, why? It'd be useful and a good demonstration of arbitrage.
In particular in this case, the issue is not that the ads had 0 value themselves. Obviously, as you point out, his sites had some value. However, that value is clearly less than that of actually relevant search results (or so Google, the worlds foremost authority on search results, believes). Therefore the profit comes from externalizing the costs, rather than from value creation.
But nonetheless, I think they are adding value. Here's why i think that:
A. Customer utility (for a subset of customers) is higher for search results presented in the style of Sourcetool than in the style of Google. (i.e. Google isn't all things to all men - no shame in that).
B. Those customers do not know about Sourcetool, but do know about Google. (market inefficiency = imperfect knowledge)
So assuming this customer ultimately wants sourcetool style results, there are three steps to be taken:
0. Customers goes to www.google.com
1. Google refers them to Sourcetool
2. Source tool provides the desired services (even if that includes serving an ad)
In this scenario, both Google and Sourcetool should capture the value associated with giving the customer what they want - they both played a part.
I dont know if both parties are capturing value, but its certainly true that they both could. Google gets paid by the advertiser who places the ad served by AdSense, so even if Google's two transactions with Sourcetool are net negative, Google may well be coming out net positive with the inclusion of the transaction of the AdSense advertiser.
Seems to me that Google should merely be setting is rev-sharing terms with Sourcetool to ensure that both parties capture value.
tom saffell
They should also be willing and able to tell you whether or not you paid for a particular click in your logs. I have had difficulty getting that information from them.
People currently do this, but it's very unpredictable due to lack of information. With information, some advertisers would be more informed than others and have an advantage - this is not what Google wants because informed advertisers spend less and I suspect Google would rather have uninformed "stupid" advertisers wasting $1000s per month propping up their business.