- More variety in memory layout (different topologies, hidden caves that can be entered only if you control a location, bots can influence the layout while in game...)
- Special instructions that grant special abilities like memory protection, but at a computational or memory cost
- More resource types (different executing CPUs with different strengths/weaknesses, different memory nodes harder/easier to access like a queue, extra hardware gadgets you can take over like TIS-1000 nodes)
- Game progression (research side quests to get additional special HW, at either one-time resource cost or via special task like guessing a password, deciding NP complete instance..)
- Additional game goal types (capture the flag, first to finish computing a neutral program wins)
Just a few. The game concept has a lot of potential.
I can imagine strategies of stealing competing warriors' work or corrupting data.
I wonder if you could do like, ASLR core wars somehow.
also befunge wars would be fun but break me.
So I wrote a version where every thread was running at the same speed, but that was always dominated by very simple replicators.
Then I tried to figure out how to have an instruction set where all instructions run at the same time. But I could not come up with something that worked well.
Recently I wrote a "cellular automaton with provenance" thing. Basically game of life, but you track the originator of each cell. That is fun, but also does not lead to a good game as far as I can see.
Perhaps you can make your idea work with some more real world ideas?
In the real world, you need resources to do anything. You find resources in the environment. Be that water, food or sunlight etc.
In Core Wars processing power is a resource. In standard Core Wars, your side has a fixed supply of resources. Replicating just divides that fixed supply amongst more agents. Somewhat realistic.
You can steal other people's processing power, if you manage to make some of their threads execute your code. (In that weirder sense, replicating in Core Wars can give you more processing power.)
Your idea was to hand out the resource of processing power just in relation to how many times you replicated. You found that's not workable.
Perhaps you could come up with a way to make players earn processing power?
I suppose you could make it more interesting by battling it out on real systems, a mix of Core War and CTF if you like.
Fortunately there are other programming games such as Robocode, Screeps, yare.io, etc.
is only a crude approximation.