I went to your site and signed in with Twitter. Now it is asking me for my email address and to choose a password. If I wanted that, I would have chosen the "sign up with e-mail" option. Could you fulfill the promise of single sign-on?
We did make it so you can sign up with email (not just Twitter/Facebook) and we made the form as simple as possible.
We're still not sure what's best overall. I'm positive we'll take down the sign up wall at some point though.
Since people's biggest concern with getting product recommendations is that they're biased it's a big plus on our site.
I know it's super unpopoular position for some, but Yelp has been doing it for a very long time with great success.
We're going to do some more Twitter integration stuff though, so it might still be worthwhile.