Heavy Wears the Crown and the Kohinoor
marginalrevolution.com
marginalrevolution.com
However, that is only half the story.
It was actually mined in southern India, in what is today Andhra Pradesh. Then, it was in the possession of the Kakatiya dynasty who ruled that part of India. Then, the Kalji dynasty of the Delhi Sultanate, invaded south India, and ended up receiving that diamond as tribute. Then later, Babur, the founder of the Mogul dynasty, received it as tribute after defeating the Delhi Sultanate at the Battle of Paniput.
Delighted to discover it was in fact ripped off from one of his other books and that there's a series of 4 he wrote on the history of the general area/time period.
It's like saying Ethiopia lost control of its infrastructure due to a raid by Benito Mussolini, an Italian bandit.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koh-i-Noor
Edit append:
At this time, it belonged to [Queen Victoria] personally, and was not yet part of the Crown Jewels. Although Victoria wore it often, she became uneasy about the way in which the diamond had been acquired. In a letter to her eldest daughter, Victoria, Princess Royal, she wrote in the 1870s: "No one feels more strongly than I do about India or how much I opposed our taking those countries and I think no more will be taken, for it is very wrong and no advantage to us. You know also how I dislike wearing the Koh-i-Noor".
Famously, the vikings & the mongols come to mind. But this is equally true for parties rallying around religion, whether it is islamic or christian colonisation.
The European colonisation started largely triggered by
1. Turkey (Ottoman empire) extracting large tributes from Europe to import goods from India.
2. The doctrine of christian discovery whereby a christian ("white") can claim territory or property "discovered" by him in the name of the church. So a lot of claim on land whether in Australia or America falls under this. Even inventions can be "rediscovered".
In the case of India, with the exception of Islamic or European colonisation, much of the royal wealth can be attributed to trade and Kings/Queens building infrastructure, cities and trade routes. Temples which also acted as banks financing large merchant navies that had established trade routes all over the Indian ocean territory.In the case of China, even though extracting tributes was common and there very frequent genocidal conflicts between the kingdoms, trade was a major source of wealth as the silk-route shows.
I don't understand this "Indian exceptionalism" point of view that seems more prevalent these days. I suppose if you retroactively apply some national idea of "india" that was foreign to people living in the Indian subcontinent at the time, and ignore all the plundering and conquest that routinely and commonly happened between those states.
States like the mughal empire didn't spread and conquest thanks to sunshine and rainbows. Even looking at the kohinoor itself it was routinely stolen and taken by force by different factions across India.
And just like the rest of the world (china as you point out but also very much Europe as well) India of course benefited through trade as well. But I don't see how there is anything unique or different about it.
A nation and a state are two completely different concepts.
A nation is peoples, tribes and ethnic groups that, in spite of differences, have something in common that binds them. A state is an ephemeral entity: lines on a map drawn by a power that will fade in time and be replaced with something else. So, while there have been multiple "states" and kingdoms on the Indian subcontinent over millennia, the Indian "nation" has always been there.
What is that then? Because it can't be race, religion, language etc etc.
Really the nation of "India" was created by Britain. It is perfectly easy to imagine an alternative history where the Raj never existed, states in the Indian subcontinent weren't united and so no modern Indian nation as we know it today was ever birthed.
In this view, the Indian "nation" would be like the European "nation" - a fiction. Just because a bunch of people live there with some similar religion and some cultural similarities at a very high level, does not a nation make.
I can imagine in 100 years European nationalists of some new EU state trying to invent a history of the European "nation" that predates their state all through history. But it is just stories with no basis in reality.
It can be all of those or none of those. A tribe or ethnic group can be a nation by itself. They could join other similar peoples to form a nation if there is strong cultural commonality. A bunch of anime-loving randos living in the same apartment complex does not make them a nation.
> Really the nation of "India" was created by Britain.
The state or political entity that is India is a descendant of the Raj. To say that a people who have no sense of their own nation created the Indian nation is a joke. What you can say is that the political entity that represents the English Crown created the political entity that is the Republic of India.
> the European "nation" - a fiction.
The European "nation" IS a fiction. There is no shared ethnicity, language, religion or culture. That is why the project is doomed to fail. Pan-Africanism, Pan-Arabism, Pan-Europeanism etc will never work because there is no glue that can bind the different nations together.
Let's apply the same logic to India
> There is no shared ethnicity,
India has more than two thousand ethnic groups
> language,
There are 22 officially recognised languages in India. That's out of 122 major languages spoken in India.
> religion
79.8% of the population of India practices Hinduism, 14.2% adheres to Islam, 2.3% adheres to Christianity, 1.7% adheres to Sikhism, 0.7% adheres to Buddhism, and 0.4% adheres to Jainism
> or culture.
Definition of culture is too complex, but I'd say it's as varied (or probably more varied than) European.
With strong cultural bonds. You put a guy from Karnataka in the same room as someone from Assam and they will have more in common with each other than someone from Ireland with someone from Turkey.
> There are 22 officially recognized languages in India.
You can roam most of India if you known two languages: English and Hindi. Can you say the same thing about Europe?
> 79.8% of the population of India practices Hinduism, 14.2% adheres to Islam, 2.3% adheres to Christianity, 1.7% adheres to Sikhism, 0.7% adheres to Buddhism, and 0.4% adheres to Jainism
If you know about the partition of India, you will also know that it was the result of the "two-nation" theory,[1] the idea that Hindus and Muslims were two separate nations sharing the same political borders and that each nation should have its own state.
While modern India is a predominantly Hindu country, the significant percentage of Muslims who continue to live here after the partition gave them their own country keeps the theory alive. The constant riots and political conflicts between Hindus and Muslims is proof of this.
Ah yes. But if you put someone from Ireland with someone from Italy, they will have as much in common as those to guys you mentioned.
> You can roam most of India if you known two languages: English and Hindi.
Ah yes. English. How did you put it? "To say that a people who have no sense of their own nation created the Indian nation is a joke."
And now you mention English (before Hindi) as a "shared language".
Additionally, "Although Widely Spoken, Around 56% of Indians Don't Identify Hindi as Their Mother Tongue" [1]
> If you know about the partition of India,
Doesn't matter what I think or two-nations theory. The fact is that India has as much "shared religion" as Europe.
[1] https://www.news18.com/news/india/although-widely-spoken-hin...
You should get your timelines in order. English is used in modern India. However, like everywhere else, if you go back in time, the invaders imposed their language and customs on the local population. If the Chinese had conquered Central and South America instead of the Europeans, Mexico and Brazil would be speaking Chinese today instead of Spanish and Portuguese. That doesn't mean that American civilizations were ignorant or uncivilized or that they didn't have their own languages.
> Additionally, "Although Widely Spoken, Around 56% of Indians Don't Identify Hindi as Their Mother Tongue"
Doesn't matter. Most people understand the language as a lot of Indians are multilingual.
> The fact is that India has as much "shared religion" as Europe.
Only someone who doesn't understand Hindus and their religion can make such assertions. What is called Hinduism has been a way of life across the subcontinent for millennia. Even the name is irrelevant. People don't "become" Hindus. They simply "are."
The characters and stories in our sacred texts are not about incidents that happened in Arabia and Africa that is then taught to children in Poland or Ireland or Turkey who have nothing to do with them. They are about our ancestors in this very place. While peoples within Europe might have something similar, Europe as a political entity will never have it.
It wasn't me who gave English as an example for a shared language.
> Doesn't matter. Most people understand the language
There are over a billion people in the world who understand English. By your logic they all "share a language" etc.
> The characters and stories in our sacred texts are not about incidents that happened in Arabia and Africa that is then taught to children in Poland or Ireland or Turkey who have nothing to do with them. They are about our ancestors in this very place
They are as much your ancestors as Germanic tribes are ancestors to half the Europe.
And as any heroic ancestors they would slit each other's throats if the other looked at them funny.
> While peoples within Europe might have something similar, Europe as a political entity
As a political entity India came to be because of the Brits. Prior to that it was an ever changing tapestry of various states (like literally everywhere else in the world) at near constant war with each other (again, like literally everywhere else in the world).
"Shared language" in this context is your own phrasing. My examples refer to intelligibility.
> By your logic they all "share a language" etc.
That is your logic. A common language may not be sufficient to produce and hold a nation.
> Germanic tribes are ancestors to half the Europe.
The Cholas were in Tamil Nadu when Julius Caesar invaded Great Britain.[1] They were here during the Viking invasions. When the Normans invaded, the Cholas were still here in Tamil Nadu doing their thing.
We have been here as a continuous civilization for millennia while maintaining our culture. The same cannot be said about Europe.
> As a political entity India came to be because of the Brits.
The modern Republic of India, yes. If it has not been obvious from my very first comment, I don't really care about political entities because they come and go through processes which may or may not be violent.
What matters to me is the preservation of the language and culture of peoples: civilization. Which does not happen if they are assimilated, replaced or victims of genocide like in Britain, Palestine or the Americas.
India does not have to impose uniformity on its population in the form of language or culture precisely because it is a civilisation.
Great uniformity, indeed.
I'm trying and failing to see who is it that is imposing uniformity on Europeans in the form of language or culture.
At different times yes, but there have been Empires of significant size for several centuries. India is about the size of western Europe, and people have have a shared civilisational history in the form of epics.
> I'm trying and failing to see who is it that is imposing uniformity on Europeans in the form of language or culture.
Conflating linguistic or cultural homogeneity with nationhood is a European limitation, does not apply to India. The EU is constantly struggling with "Integration" and Brexit is a result of the inability to expand beyond language barriers.
Civilization is a step above culture, but takes longer to establish.
A neighbouring country like Nepal or Sri Lanka can if they desire in the future merge with Bharat without having to "intergrate" or change themselves in any way.
That is because they have a shared cultural and historical continuity as part of an ancient civilisation. And India is pluralistic in its very nature.
European nations a too narrow in their idea of nation - linguistic, cultural. It would be impossible for them to expand beyond this narrow idea.
Inspite of this it is still one nation, while the EU is constantly bickering about trivial things. It requires more than a thousand years to establish a civilisation, and India is a civilisation temporarily trapped in a weak western concept of a nation state.
>> Really the nation of "India" was created by Britain.
India has been recognised as a single entity for a long time before the British, for instance the Ancient Romans, Chinese, Arabs and Greeks.
So has "Europe" been recognised as a "single entity". Or "Christendom" or many other entities.
The reason India is a single state is because of an accident of history - that Britain colonised it, built a ruling elite and civil service, and so constructed it as a state. If it weren't for that accident of history, India would most likely be as it was before - a collection of states "bickering about trivial things".
Britain has been known for divide and rule, especially for a region like India that has had a long history of massive Empires. Let us remember that the British did leave India as a collection of 600+ princely states. It was the Indians who convinced them to join the union.
The EU was formed with trade as a carrot to prevent them from going at each others throats, we have had Brexit in spite of that.
The Arabs are famously have a mostly homogeneous religion and language but have been at each others throats.
India is an old and continuous civilisation, it takes a lot of trial, error and learning to have a long running civilisation.
You... aren't thinking very hard then.
What has been the single most globally dominant power since it eclipsed the waning British Empire, and how did it form? (The correct answer to the second question is “Under British rule but very much not according to British intention”.)
And it was a big country when it formed, though not as big as it is now.
The US in spite of its tall claim of being a melting pot is essentially a white christian Anglo-Saxon country.
It is a Britains own lebensraum, perhaps not including the old aristocrats.
With the other 20% being Russia. And China apart from a few ports. And South America apart from Guiana. And Central America apart from Belize. And Mexico. And Greenland. And the entire rest of Europe.
I think your math is a bit off...
Yes you are right I went with rhetoric, but nevertheless Britain had significant parts of the world as a colony at one point or the other.
The idea that Britain intentionally or unintentionally created India when Indians did not see it as one is BS.
Humans do like to lump together foreign entities that share some similarity. That's not recognition, that's not knowing better. Often augmented by, to put it politely, submaximal respect. Not even the lump that became namesake to the term "balkanized" is immune to generalizations.
India is among the least policed state, so it is not the power of the state that is holding it together.
A lot of people have been predicting the "balkanisation" of India and many are actively working towards that but to no fruition.
That is a colonial view point, surely the Indians traded with the Romans or the Ancient Greeks, they were distinctly seen as Indians/Hindus and I am sure the Indians were aware of it.
>> the mughal empire
As I mentioned, they are part of the Islamic expansionism. The "mughals" famously rallied around islam, extracted tributes and jiziya and also sent tributes to the caliph (in Afganistan/Iran?).
>> very much Europe as well
Until very recently much of the European wealth can be attributed to colonisation, territorial expansionism (Americas) & slavery. The trade at best can be described as mercantilism (checkout salt tax).
I was just pointing out to the previous poster that the wealth of Ancient India/China can be attributed to trade and infrastructure, very much like the world today.
And a lot of it including the royal jewels (subject in question) can be attributed to plunder, piracy or colonisation.
So the idea that all kingdoms made their wealth through plunder is false. Plunder and mindless extraction are very efficient way to expand an empire, but not all empires are built that way and perhaps not very efficient or sustainable today.
Northern European growth went above trend for the rest of civilization starting in the 1300s, well before the Age of Exploration or colonization. Things accelerated with the Great Divergence, when the Industrial Revolution spread starting in the 1800s. Colonialism was a result of becoming rich and powerful far more than a cause. See the lack of effects on GDP per capita with losing an empire after WW2, or how Nordic countries were near as rich as Britain or Austria-Hungary as rich as Germany.
> Accounting for the ‘Little Divergence’ What drove economic growth in preindustrial Europe, 1300-1800?
> The Little Divergence is the process of differential economic growth within Europe in the period between 1300 and 1800, during which the North Sea Area developed into the most prosperous and dynamic part of the Continent. We test various hypotheses about the causes of the Little Divergence, using new data and focusing on trends in GDP per capita. The results are that institutional changes (in particular the rise of active Parliaments), human capital formation and structural change are the primary drivers of the growth that occurred, which contrast sharply with previous findings by Robert Allen (who however focused on real wages as dependent variable). We also test for the role of religion (the spread of Protestantism): this has affected human capital formation, but does not in itself have an impact on growth. Moreover, we find an insignificant effect of the land-labour ratio, which shows the limitations of the Malthusian model for understanding the Little Divergence.
https://ideas.repec.org/p/ucg/wpaper/0046.html#:~:text=The%2....
Revolution like Renaissance is often suggestive of a sudden explosion of new ideas, but in reality it requires an active transfer of knowledge or takes a really long time to establish.
Successful colonisation can be attributed to the political unity brought about by the church, very much the same way Islam allowed the various Arab tribes to bring down the mighty Persian empire.
For quite sometime the East India company was working as a mercenary making deals with smaller kingdoms, the concentration of wealth from exports to Europe did give them the resources to initially run trading ports and eventually become the force behind the famed puppet rajas, often children.
The Europeans rarely engaged in direct conflict until much later when they had amassed enormous power.
That's oddly specific. What starting date do you put on the Industrial Revolution, and why do you pick that exact starting date?
I would have described the Industrial Revolution as a gradual process, building up over a century or so. What basis is there for picking one specific year and saying "that's the start"?
The French had a separate ministry for espionage.
Columbus set out precisely to find a trade route to India and Vasco da Gama eventually managed by circumnavigating Africa with the precise intent of finding a route to India to import goods into Europe.
Similar to renaissance, the sudden explosion of enlightenment or industrialisation did not happen, there was significant transfer of knowledge, materials and skills from very likely India.
And like with renaissance, this is often covered up. I do not see why there is a need to deny that today, it has happened through out history and is quite suspicious that something happened independently.
"Official"? Official by whose definition?
Wikipedia (yeah, I know) says "... in the period from about 1760 to sometime between 1820 and 1840", and "The precise start and end of the Industrial Revolution is still debated among historians, as is the pace of economic and social changes."
So where do you get this "official" year?
> the coincidence is too compelling.
Because Britain setting up trading ports in India was the only possibly relevant thing that happened in the previous N years? Did India teach Britain how to make steam engines? How to make factories? No and no.
> The French had a separate ministry for espionage.
How is this relevant to the conversation?
> Similar to renaissance, the sudden explosion of enlightenment or industrialisation did not happen, there was significant transfer of knowledge, materials and skills from very likely India.
There was a transfer of at least knowledge, but a lot of it came from the Arabs, by way of the Eastern Roman Empire. When Constantinople fell to the Arabs, a lot of that knowledge went west. Some of that knowledge may have originated in India, but it certainly wasn't direct.
You seem to be trying desperately to make the Industrial Revolution be all about India. You seem to be trying to squeeze actual history into your view, but it does not fit all that well.
No, I am just saying if Europeans were desperately looking for a trade route to India specifically. Specifically for the purpose of importing manufactured goods.
When Europeans like the French had "ministry for espionage", which must definitely be a thing in the other Europeans especially for their arch rivals.
If the bulk of the knowledge had already been transmitted by the arabs, there would not be a need for the Europeans to be in India.
If you are denying that a significant amount of knowledge and skills had not been transmitted given the above, I guess you are the one in denial.
Anyway my point is that pretending that India was a non-entity before British colonisation and it was somehow British benevolence that created/built "India" is utter BS, if anything it was the other way around.
> You seem to be trying to squeeze actual history into your view, but it does not fit all that well.
No, history has been written by the Europeans, wrt. their colonies. Given strong evidence to the contrary, I guess we need to reexamine the idea of Industrial revolution devoid of significant Indian contribution both direct and indirect.
An external group calling you "indians" is pretty thin cloth for saying that the Indian nation has a long history as a nation.
Nobody is denying that people in an area often have cultural similarities. Similarly you will find ancient sources talking about "Africa" or "Europe" or "Asia" but it doesn't mean that these are all automatically nations, or that if someone in the future invents a nation in those locales - it doesn't mean that said nation has an ancient history as a nation - although there will be no shortage of people trying to retcon history like in India.
> Until very recently much of the European wealth can be attributed to colonisation, territorial expansionism (Americas) & slavery. The trade at best can be described as mercantilism (checkout salt tax).
I mean, this just isn't true. I have noticed when I have been in India that people there like to construct some fiction about how all the wealth in Britain or even Europe in general was stolen in some giant zero sum game from India. But in reality - many studies have really shown again and again that India was a prestige project that made some aristocrats wealthy but the overall impact on the UK was negative. A bit like with wars and occupations we see today - such as the recent gulf war - there's some who promote it, are influential, and even get wealthy, but the overall effect on the occupying country is a net negative economically.
Just as the Scandinavian countries share the Norse mythology.
> like to construct some fiction about how all the wealth
The only fiction is in the minds of colonial apologists, the coincidence of the impoverishment of India along with the rise of Europe is too hard to miss.
> India was a prestige project
You mean the Europeans funded hundreds of ships desperately to find an alternate trade route to India, for a prestige project? What next the whole colonisation & slavery was a prestige project to export human rights.
The mercantile policies of the crown were very clear, banning the construction of ships or locomotives, taxing salt to such an extent that it was cheaper to import salt from Britain.
While it is true that aristocrats became insanely rich, and very many Brits lived miserable lives far worse than in many princely states. It is merely due the rigid "class/caste" system that was prevalent in Europe esp. in Britain.
Colonial wealth definitely played a singular role in making Europe wealthy today.
This literally goes back to the Bronze Age and Carthage. Rome’s public treasury was a temple. (And the claim that India was peaceful before colonisation begs explanation for the country being dotted by gorgeous forts. Who were they fortifying against?)
As someone with Indian heritage, I think I can safely express bemusement at the mirroring of 19th century white ethnocentrism in modern Indian exceptionalism.
A region where only plundering dominated would be perpetually reset to square 1.
The wealth of ancient India or China can be attributed to the fact that trade was a dominant force, though that does not rule out conflicts between kingdoms.
The Hindu rules of war explicitly rules out destruction of civilian assets or scorched earth strategies, something quite the norm in other parts of the world. This is true in modern warfare, a big difference between modern states and the likes of ISIS.
Everyone says this. Literally, everyone. Again, going back to Roman treatises on fighting honourably and this and that.
Everyone says this. Everyone bends to reality from time to time. If you’re claiming there were zero, or even a shockingly small number, of kingdoms razed with civilians slaughtered in pre-colonial India, you aren’t consulting historical sources.
(Similar to the claim that India and China gained from trading in a way that is distinct from e.g. the Aztecs or Dutch. Lots of trading empires across history. Many of them relatively peaceful, at least for a time.)
This is precisely what we follow in the modern world so should not be surprised.
In practice it is not honour but just practical unless you want to constantly engaged in conflict with your "new" citizens.
A problem sidestepped across anqituity, including in India, by killing and/or enslaving the conquered population.
Except that what you want most is the knowledge and skills of the population.
It was attempted multiple times, especially around the same time Hitler was busy with his project in Europe, he definitely wasn't alone with his ideas.
Other societies had trade focus - I'm thinking of the Hanseatic League and Renaissance Venice - but they also had a military arm used to "protect trade routes", which all too often meant discouraging/destroying other people trying to attempt trade on the same routes. I would not be surprised if we found the same being true for Indian merchant navies.
Destroying others using the same routes will only make you poorer, so I guess that is not what long lasting, successful kingdoms would have chosen to do.
Especially suspect given that they were fighting a Nawab.
And that doesn't say much given the long history.
Nawab == Muslim. Hence must be a terrible person. I understand that sentiment, it's practically a religious doctrine amongst Indian right wingers.
He gave half the value to the Queen, which she used to pay off the country’s debt. The other half made him a very wealthy man.
I can’t wait for the movie this Friday! https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1464335/
Of course the difference wasn't always clear, especially as privateers generally favored attacking the enemy's commerce shipping rather than their warships. So it was seen as cowardly as well as profitable.
This jewel was not strictly pirated by the British. Though peace deals are signed under duress, of course.