How to figure out the size of the moon yourself
profmattstrassler.com
profmattstrassler.com
2) Adjust distance of thumb from face until it just barely occludes vision of the moon.
3) Holding very still, use accurate calipers to measure thumb.
Under many repetitions with many different experimenters, this should consistently yield a result showing that the width of the moon is one thumb wide.
https://sky-lights.org/2018/10/01/qa-determining-asteroid-sh...
The story itself is pretty cool. The idea was presented in 1663, and it wasn't until 1761 and 1769 that the planets would align. And, this also doesn't happen all that often, although it comes in pairs. 1761 and 1769, 1874 and 1882, 2004 and 2012. And it won't happen again until 2117. So, this was considered so important, and the transit of Venus had to be observed from distances far away on earth. In spite of wars going on, these expeditions were given safe passage.
Yet I can't help but wonder from a history of science point of view, how much the above exercise is "presuming the conclusion". Organizing an international star party to see where the moon is at the same time requires knowing what the concept of same time on very different places on earth. But historically, the concept of same time was heavily dependent on astronomical measurements -- both astronomical knowledge and advanced instruments. Now if you start using modern techs like GPS to figure out what the concept of same time is, you're already relying on satellites and can probably use that tech to make a direct measurement of the size of the moon.
It does depend on accurate surveying over distances exceeding the diameter of the moon, and a good deal of communication, which I suspect is enough of a problem to answer the author's question of why it was not done, as far as we know. The method is not, however, begging the question.
[1] https://www.eg.bucknell.edu/physics/astronomy/astr101/specia....
Indeed, were there any premodern civilisations with a sufficient span of latitudes to perform this method? If there were, they'd have also been able to measure the distance to the Sun using the method of observing transits of Venus.
We're currently in the Mayan Dark Ages in that sense, there's stuff they had we still can't do. They were a millennium ahead of Eurasian math, finding zero in 200BC versus 800AD.
I'm skeptical, how would we know that? Are there vague inscriptions of things like Fermat's margin notes that imply missing knowledge?
In 1663 Scottish mathematician James Gregory had suggested in his Optica Promota that observations of a transit of the planet Mercury, at widely spaced points on the surface of the Earth, could be used to calculate the solar parallax and hence the astronomical unit using triangulation. Aware of this, a young Edmond Halley made observations of such a transit on 28 October O.S. 1677
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transit_of_Venus#1761_and_1769
The moon takes up about 1/100,000 of the night sky [0].
In excellent conditions you can see maybe 5,000 stars [1]. So on average the moon is blocking 0.05 of them.
It's surprising how small the moon is in the sky, given its prominence, and how few stars there are even on the blackest night.
Now correct for the fact that you won't have perfect viewing conditions everywhere in your survey area, and that you can make out far fewer stars when the moon is full, and a few opportunities a month starts to look reasonable.
[0] https://www.quora.com/How-much-of-the-full-night-sky-does-th...
[1] https://skyandtelescope.org/astronomy-blogs/how-many-stars-n...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_period#Small_body_orbi...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_gravitational_paramet...
[3] https://www.wolframalpha.com/input?i=%28%28%5C%5BMu%5D+T%5E2...
First we'll consider the mass of the Moon substantially smaller than that of the Earth and that its orbit is circular. In this case, in its orbit around the Earth, the weight of the Moon is the centripetal force:
W = F_cp
mg = mw^2R (R being orbit Radius)
g = w^2R
GM/R^2 = w^2R
Assuming you have the gravity g_e on the surface of the Earth and its radius R_e, we can derive GM (M being the mass of the Earth):
GM/R_e^2 = g_e
GM = g_e * R_e^2
Replacing GM on the previous equation, we get:
g_e * R_e^2/R^2 = w^2R
R = (g_e * R_e^2 / w^2)^(1/3)
Note that w (angular velocity of the Moon) is easy to calculate: 28 days per rotation and gravity on the surface of the Earth is around 9.8 meters per second. Radius of the Earth can be calculated by other means. Nevertheless, we now have an approximation for the orbital radius of the Moon. Considering the Radius of the Earth, distance to the Moon from someone at the surface of the Earth is given by:
D = R - R_e
Now, to calculate the radius of the visible Moon disk using triangle similarity, use a small disk (with radius r) and hold it at a distance d from your eye until it becomes the same apparent size of the Moon disk. Applying similarity of triangles, the radius r_m of the Moon is given by:
r_m/D = r/d
r_m = D*r/d
Note that we are no calculating the radius of the Moon, but the radius of the visible Moon disk. Considering D is much bigger than d, it is a good approximation.
I wonder how precise this will turn out though.
Personal anecdote: a gifted uncle of mine once calculated the duration of total Moon eclipse using similar methods. Distance to the Moon was approximated to 1.5 light-seconds. He got the estimated time wrong by around 5 minutes. He did it using mental calculations only.
Then, if you have a few friends who know what day it is in different countries, you can find out how large the moon's shadow is on the Earth.
The rest is just math.
1. They didn't know how far away the stars were. The stars might as well be illuminated dots on a sphere that is surrounding the earth not too far away.
2. Also you'd have to measure the time very precisely at several quite distant points on the Earth's surface. Not an easy feat.
Despite being expensive, it had successful kickstarter campaigns and via its app you can join campaigns with your telescope and contribute to science. Kinda neat.
I guess it shouldn't surprise me that a site dedicated to scientific information would be dense in well, information (not trendy with flashy graphics, little content nor confusing color schemes where you can't figure out what is a link or not)
It seems harder to recruit a load of people to look at the sky.
I think part of the assumption is that this is still trying to use a method theoretically available to ancient Greeks and pre Brahe and Kepler before the laws of planetary motion were discovered.