> This is a world that feels compelled to pass laws requiring the use of seat belts and motorcycle helmets in the hope of protecting people who are too stupid to wear them otherwise.
Does anyone really have a problem with mandating basic safety? Can you say this is actually causing harm without extrapolating and theorizing?
> If your car runs out of gasoline and you manage to walk to a gas station, you cannot buy gasoline in anything other than an government approved container. The fact that you are stranded makes no difference.
This one's valid, but I also don't see the practical problem here. Gas stations can just stock jerry cans as needed, it's not that big of a deal. Maybe this one can be done away with.
> If someone falls off a ladder while painting your house, they can sue you and take your house.
This is a matter of liability, a concept I'm sure we all can say is something we should keep around to avoid acting like toddlers. There are situations where they deserve to be compensated for their injury, and there are situations where they don't, and most court systems will attempt to distinguish the two. Now, if your court system sucks, it may not make a great decision but that's neither here nor there.
> This is a world that no longer allows you to purchase hydrogen peroxide above a certain concentration for fear you will use it to make a bomb.
Unless I'm missing something, this is also false. You can buy 50% hydrogen peroxide here without a license https://www.fishersci.ca/shop/products/hydrogen-peroxide-50-.... Is that high enough?
Yes. That is why he included the example.
It is totally ridiculous that if I do something that puts myself at a minor risk then I get funnelled into a system where the options are compliance or imprisonment.
The situation is complicated somewhat by the fact that as far as we call tell a rational person should agree with what the system is demanding, and it isn't important enough to fight about. But nevertheless, imprisonment should not be a theoretical outcome for someone wilfully choosing not to wear a seatbelt.
I don't know, I'm not a domain expert. Maybe they don't imprison people for that and just bankrupt them. Still wildly disproportionate and an idiotic formal response to a minor bad decision.
> Still wildly disproportionate and an idiotic formal response to a minor bad decision.
Any interaction with the justice system has to have imprisonment at the end of the line. Not because that's the right way to do it, but because it just doesn't work otherwise. Let's imagine a scenario where a law is passed saying you cannot be imprisoned for a speeding ticket under any circumstances. As long as you don't get in an accident, you can go 150mph down the highway and you won't go to jail.
Okay so you get a ticket for an obscene amount of money. But you can't pay it, or you just don't. Do we just throw our hands up and say "shucks, you got us on that one?" Even if you have wages to garnish or property to forfeit, you'd have to take those costs into account and now for a $500 ticket you're having your car repo'd or your wages garnished by 10% for months. It doesn't seem like an oppressive socialist hellscape to me to just say "you know what, you either pay your ticket or you go to jail, and if you're going fast enough, just go straight to jail."
1st paragraph - that looks like someone bearing the costs for their bad decision personally to me. Which is why they should be the one making the decision.
2nd & 3rd - yep. That comes close to the extended argument for why it is stupid to legally mandate wearing seatbelts. The level of threat required to enforce a minor requirement is absurd. People shouldn't be subjected to that sort of legal hazard without a high bar of justification.
On the other hand, however, a lot of people exist as parts of families and communities. They don't need to be mandated not to harm themselves in acts of sheer stupidity because they think about the consequences of their own actions and would be mortified to imagine themselves in a situation where medical resources are being expended on them for no other reason than their own narcissism.
But more to the point, at times the task of a democracy boils down to deciding which of these two sorts of personality the society should be geared towards supporting or whether it makes sense to limit the amount of damage that lunatics and sociopths and can do to themselves or to the rest of us for that matter.
It isn't. You might get cited for not wearing a seatbelt and then through your own stupidity get thrown in jail but the seatbelt citation alone won't do it.
The point about seatbelts is particularly asinine because someone not wearing a seatbelt is not just endangering themselves.
In a car it is pretty easy for a person without a seatbelt to become a hundred plus pound projectile. For instance a belted driver sees something in the road and swerves to avoid it; an unbelted person in the front passenger seat unaware of the maneuver will bounce around likely interfering with the driver's control of the car. If the passenger hits their head and is knocked unconscious they're going to rag doll around the inside of the car.
A lot of people only think of head on collisions with regard to seatbelts. They don't consider (like the author) all of the non-impact events that can happen in a car and cause people to fly around the passenger compartment. Just slamming on the brakes can throw someone through a window or into the front console.
Yeah, but you're classing "not wearing a seatbelt" as "your own stupidity" in that line of reasoning. If someone persistently and willfuly attempts to drive without wearing a seatbelt (and, obviously, the legal system is aware of it) then the outcome is going to be imprisonment sooner or later.
The fact that nobody is stupid enough to throw away their lives over seatbelts doesn't change the logical progression of what would happen to someone if they tried.
"Due to product restrictions, we cannot sell this product online. Please call Customer Service at 1-800-234-7437 or send an email to help@thermofisher.com for assistance."
My guess is there will be some ID check, or maybe they only sell to people with "legitimate need" or whatever because the feds get on their ass otherwise.
Any government that puts people on a blacklist for buying over n pounds of fertilizer, peroxide, whatever is a bad government.
Do you think these regulations just sprang up fully formed without reason? Legislation like this is written in the blood of those who came before it.
I agree that it needs to be treated with respect. Not allowing the public to access things that need to be treated with respect is indeed treating them like toddlers.
But "good decision" is not just a technical judgement. The OP claimed the U.S. courts changed their doctrine about this kind of case, at least regarding chemistry sets, around the 70s or not long before. I don't know if this is right, but it comports with other claims I've read about strict liability taking over then -- that previously, liability was a balance where adults could assume responsibility for themselves, and it was possible to sell them dangerous items if it was clear enough what they were getting, without extreme fear of lawsuits; and afterwards, not.
Maybe this claim is wrong, I don't know, but it's certainly not "neither here nor there" in this argument.
In considering whether it's overprotective, you need to account for the products and industries that never came to exist, and not just the ones that were destroyed, like https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/02/av... (first paragraph).