Somewhat related, one of the things that made me stop freelancing online when I was a teenager was the number of people who upon job completion would ask me to wait until they had the money to pay, or try to get out of paying entirely.
Somewhat related, one of the things that made me stop freelancing online when I was a teenager was the number of people who upon job completion would ask me to wait until they had the money to pay, or try to get out of paying entirely.
Most of us have this inner sense of “How dare I?” ask for money. Even when it’s earned and perfectly honest or in direct payment for your directly contributed labor.
This is what makes raising money hard and it’s what makes sales hard. And it is what allows people like this to take advantage of those who work hard without paying them for a surprisingly long time.
The fact is all these "jobfished" people signed up willingly for a job that was purely commission-based, and had the agency actually been able to attract a paying client in the first six months, who is to say Ali wouldn't have made good on his promises to hire people on salary, etc.?
I know I'm going to be downvoted for this comment, but I wanted to lay out a contrarian point of view that doesn't just immediately jump on the bandwagon of the current Anna Sorokin/Tinder Swindler zeitgeist.
If you put fake executives into an investment document with fake work samples and fake client claims, that would definitely be considered criminal fraud.
You seem very hung up on the wording of this article. Is fraud not a crime unless it's called out by a journalist?
Especially in the UK:
https://www.npr.org/sections/parallels/2015/03/21/394273902/...
b) The employees were all told they would get a salary and many were told they would get sponsored for a visa. Ali did not have the means to follow through with those promises.
I ran a legit design agency and none of this is common. And it goes well beyond a fib.
* Stealing portfolio samples (copyright infringement / IP theft & fraud)
* Creating fake employee profiles and potentially impersonating these fake employees (fraud)
* Hiring people on a $0 base salary (illegal hiring practice)
At best he didn’t know he was breaking the law, at the worst he was.
Having said that, the article noted that HMRC’s minimum wage enforcement team have already been involved and recovered just £29.70. Hopefully they’re still working on it.
Edit: An employment tribunal ruled that three employees are collectively owed £19,000, so minimum wage is somewhat being enforced. But the company doesn’t have any money to pay them. It’s a mess.
Who's to say Sorokin or the Tinder Swindler wouldn't have paid their victims back if only they'd ended up with enough money to do it?
In this case someone recruited people he didn't have a chance of paying (or getting visas for even if the money came in) to work long hours for nothing for a business based entirely on lies (not just fake projects on the website, but a fake cofounder messaging staff!), and has absolutely no regrets over it. As others have pointed out, it's pretty difficult to have that many people working on trying to generate creative agency business for you and not end up with even the tiniest amount of invoiceable work unless you're actively disinterested in getting business closed. That's a little different in scope from your average "we'll pay you after our fundraise" startup 'job' offering, even if the outcome is usually the same.
Devil's advocacy can be taken too far.
But yeah, nope. If they're that slimy up front, they've already told you they are clients you do not want.