Employee NPS: The Golden Metric for Employee Performance Review
medium.com
medium.com
I have had over 100 different direct reports over my entire career, and in all cases, I think having this number would have been a counterproductive distraction.
In a sense, this is how gig economy workers are managed now. They don't have a human manager, they interact with an app that evaluates them based solely on objective metrics. It's a kind of sociopathic management style. To the company, these workers are only people in the abstract sense. Practically, they are machines from which a specific output is expected ad measured.
OK, let's apply this to other kinds of work. Once management (or people in general) have a single number that ranks quality, it will be used. It will be relied upon. It will be gamed. Even if they start out as honest signals, they will be corrupted.
We humans are messy.
We have a long and complex history of trying to rank each other in "simple, objective" ways and it almost always ends badly.
The seminal work on this subject is Stephen Jay Gould's The Mismeasure of Man. I can't recommend it highly enough. It's one of the handful of books that really changed how I look at the world.
Months after I finished it, new "Hey, wait a minute!" thoughts kept bubbling up at random times.
Gamification does seem to be an issue though, but Performance reviews are already gamed. There is also a recency bias and the issue that business is dynamic so goals change quickly. There are attempts to resolve this but I haven't found anything decent nor do I think the scientists have.
Calibration among groups also seems quite fraught too.
The sales side seems to have the only realistic non-game-able metric which is the direct revenue they bring in.
This stuff is not healthy regardless because we know that work has a lot of personal nuance anyway.
BTW a good podcast episode on the core issue addressed from multiple fronts: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/25/opinion/ezra-klein-podcas... ---
Or maybe having an opaque performance review process is actually the best thing because it introduces enough fog to avoid gamification and more importantly people can't get overly upset... dunno.
To me it feels like employee performance is an ongoing, continuous, qualitative and subjective measurement that only a person's peers can really describe -- probably in their own varying and approximate terms.
In other words: less "NPS 6", and more: "would consider as a code reviewer during my quest to sort all variables based on string length ... but appears to make poor choices regarding bringing aromatic food into the cubicle farm".