This would be playing to their strengths. There is a much nicer command line/shell ecosystem in Linux and a much nicer GUI ecosystem in Windows.
This would be playing to their strengths. There is a much nicer command line/shell ecosystem in Linux and a much nicer GUI ecosystem in Windows.
https://www.theregister.com/2021/10/26/microsofts_uwp_unwant...
It’s not a huge surprise why Microsoft can’t rally developers behind anything.
Unfortunately, the execution was a mess. Not having any way to opt out of the sandbox was an insane decision and it led to crazy workarounds; even first-party Windows software has to do things like ship a sidecar exe to bypass the sandbox (the Store does). And troubleshooting issues with the sandbox was a pain, configuring capabilities was a pain, and there was very little in the way of iOS-style user-facing permission controls.
And don't get me started on the marketing; MS flacks kept telling devs how sandboxing benefits users while doing virtually nothing to convey those benefits to users.
But I can see it being attractive for full attention/fullscreen apps (like games) that don't use those things or by design bring their own implementations for those things, where the benefit is the reduced decision space for the developer, at the cost of the increased complexity. However, as the article states, ports are often using "compatibility layers" that are just worse versions of Wine though, so for such quasi-ports, there really is no increased complexity in using Wine instead.
That is why so few bother to support Linux OEMs, having some kind of POSIX support is enough for the large majority.
However I still disagree, structured shell with REPL like capabilities like PowerShell are so much better and so much closer to the Xerox PARC experience.
Not the GP but generally speaking it’s not a great reach to say that Linux is more widely supported than POSIX. GNU-only flags are often used in shell scripts and you’ll often find binaries are packaged as a snap or Docker container thud anyone running a non-Linux system is left to compile that project themselves.
Even WINE itself doesn’t officially support all POSIX-compatible UNIXs.
For better and worse, the POSIX spec is dead. Besides a few niche use-cases where compatibility with archaic software is necessary, Linux is the new standard for this stuff.
Linux is not a standard, because in opposite to, say, POSIX, it is not standardized, but is an everchanging implementation.
The kicker is that nobody can really undermine them unless you can create a true alternative with a more compelling license than GPL. If our industry wants to return to a truly standardized status-quo, we need to put aside our differences and collaborate on a next-gen spec that works. Considering that we barely did this in the 80s with POSIX, I seriously doubt today's developers and researchers are capable of doing it again. I'd love to be proven wrong though.