Hacker News Reader

He seems awfully biased towards Apple icons. Admittedly, some of their icons use better visual metaphors, but I can't help but wonder if his preferences have developed from his day-to-day use of Apple software, as opposed to objective evaluation of the designs.

View on HN

I think most of his analysis is reasonable, certainly I think many of the Mac icons work better at smaller sizes.

I think he cuts the Safari icon too much slack, however - I didn't realise that there were continents painted in the background of the compass, and the compass is fairly weak as a metaphor for the Web.

I think the Finder icon is poor too.

Disclosure: Another Mac user.

I have to agree with you. First time I saw the Finder icon, I thought it was a metaphor for an IM application.

I wouldn't call it unreasonable; just biased.

I guess it's hard to be objective, given the pervasiveness of operating systems. I'm sure if I ever succumb to Alzheimer's disease, my grandchildrens' names will be forgotten long before I forget how to use Windows ;-)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com