By throwing away those cookies, your browser is doing the equivalent of showing up to the Google DMV wearing a different hat / sunglasses / beard pattern every time; the agent behind the counter can't say "Oh, that's just tomxor, I know them at a glance already so I by default trust they aren't an active threat to me" and has to do the equivalent of going through the process of doing a background check on you every time.
> But Google is optimising for the 99% at the risk of locking out 1%, that seems careless to me.
It's not careless; it's extremely intentional. Google has a responsibility to protect the 99% and assumes that those who are Internet-savvy enough to do the work to wonk up their UA's thumbprinting are Internet-savvy enough to do the additional work to make that process smooth for their fancy non-defaults configuration.
At the scale they operate, you can expect Google to make the decision that benefits the 99% over the 1% most of the time (particularly when it comes to account security). They'll assuredly risk losing business by making the 1%'s auth story more inconvenient if it makes it 1% more likely that the 99% don't lose the whole farm to a hacker.
This is not a version issue, I suspect Google are just becoming more and more sensitive to users who don't fit their 99% of "uses chrome and doesn't block trackers" profile.
Heh.