Not saying it can't happen, but the forces that push commercial dev and open source dev don't seem to be the same at all.
Not saying it can't happen, but the forces that push commercial dev and open source dev don't seem to be the same at all.
Neither of us really had a good answer to that, but also neither of us expected OSS engineers to out-design designers in the general case. Basically, lack of designer input to OSS projects for whatever reason was problematic.
Perhaps it's because engineers don't solicit designer input. Perhaps it's because by the time the engineer-only project arrives on a designer's desk, it's too ugly to consider. Perhaps it's because designers don't have the same OSS ethos. Perhaps it's an illusion, and designers do give a lot of input to OSS projects, but the input is bad. Or a combination of a variety of factors.
Remember UX doesn't just mean pretty corners and can be used by your grandmother (or Homers dad, if you grandmother is in fact awesome at computers) especially in the context of tools used daily.
But I will grant you that is is often to always the case when the intended end user is someone who isn't a programmer.
If you want an OS over your OS. For those that don't, use Vi.
</text editor wars>
/thread