The role of a Wild Weasel aircraft is to tempt enemy radar operators into turning on their units and start transmitting. Whereupon the aircraft would launch an anti-radiation (radio-homing, not "nuclear") missile at the transmitter. The USAF has the AGM-88 and the Russians have the Kh-58 and the Kh-31 to do this. Note that all this happens while the Wild Weasel is being attacked by surface-to-air missiles and anti-aircraft fire.
As to why the Russians are being so ineffective at SEAD in Ukraine - no idea but I'm not going to give them any improvement suggestions.
In a serious peer-to-peer total conflict the AWACS would be shot down and the Ukrainians wouldn't be able to get away with much of anything.
I would wonder more about space-based observation, either ELINT or active radar.
If so, why does the US still rely on AWACS?
Physically, yes. There are plenty of radar satellites.
Power is a problem. AWACS radars draw dozens of kilowatts. You very much want lots of power in military radar, since you're often illuminating something that can be engineered to have a small RCS or is actively spoofing the return signal. This forces you to have big solar panels, big radiator panels for electronics waste heat, big batteries so you can actually run the radar in the 50% of the orbit when you're in Earthshade, big antenna for high gain, big fuel tanks because you have so much atmospheric drag that you're reboosting all the time. An AWACS satellite would be bus-sized, if not bigger.
This hypothetical AWACS satellite would also have the problem that it would have a perfectly predictable orbital track, so you could target it with a very high gain antenna for jamming. And, of course, antisatellite missiles exist, and AWACS birds would badly tempt future adversaries to make yet more orbital debris.
Some of these problems could be mitigated with a larger constellation, which you would want anyway so you can run lower altitudes and (as you note) better coverage. Unfortunately, running a Starlink-style megaconstellation with hardware purchased from military aerospace contractors would cost hundreds of trillions of dollars.
Several NRO birds are known to use synthetic aperture radar, (LACROSSE/ONYX) but almost certainly not for detecting aircraft in flight. Others are for detecting radiated signals. (NOSS) For civilian (-ish) attempts to launch surveillance megaconstellations, see PlanetScope: https://www.planet.com/products/planet-imagery/
It's only targeting information if it can be used to attack, which is not what we're talking about here.
edit: not awacs but gives and idea of the monitoring they willing to have public
https://globe.adsbexchange.com/?icao=ae01d1,ae01d5,ae01d0,ae...
It’s clear there is a lot of other kit flying there too, judging by the number of aerial refuelling planes (which show up on civilian trackers).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zt5j2mrXLks
The AWACS normally monitor Russian aircraft during peace in any case, in order to gather info about how they operate. These flights today are a goldmine of intel, as it shows how the Russian Aviation forces operate in a real conflict.
They were desperate to read those. /s
Sort of a monkeys writing Shakespeare thing. It may not be of value, but why take the chance of your conscience or nationality dictates neutrality.
It's probably why they're not as effective as we thought.
The hypothesis seems plausible to me. Feel free to let me know where this information may be incorrect so I can update my knowledge.
I read somewhere that Soviet-style air defense turn out to be most effective against Soviet-style air forces. Basically Western militaries have never invested heavily in SAMs, but invested heavily in anti-SAM weapons an tactics; while Soviet-style militaries did the opposite. That leaves Soviet-style forces with with very good SAM capabilities and weak air forces without the ability to counter it.
Hm, I will cynically say that it looks like the Russians were actually more interested in defense, while the Americans were more interested in offense.
My country was invaded by Russians in 1968. While it wasn't particularly pleasant, I think it was better than being bombed, or perhaps even, economically starved.
1. Russians won the WW2 using tanks on land, Americans won the WW2 using aircrafts over sea.
2. (If we assume Russians care less about the loss of their troops than Americans.) Attacking another country from the air is more expensive, but safer, than attacking it from the ground.
3. (If we assume Americans are more interested in projecting their force globally than Russians are.) It is easier to move airplanes/missiles/drones around the world on ships than to move heavy mechanized ground troops.
On the other hand, Russians have sometimes led the development of heavy ICBMs and nuclear weapons, but that also seems to be more valuable as a global deterrent rather than something you would randomly use during an invasion.
Have you heard of the stinger, that the Ukrainians are using to great effect? The US also has the patriot and aegis systems which are really good air defense missiles. That’s not including THAAD, etc.
That's not at all what I said. I suppose it would have been a little clearer if I had said "never invested as heavily" in SAMs compared to the Soviets, but I wasn't focusing on the West. I was making a point about Soviet-style forces fighting one another.
Nothing about that implies the West never invested in SAMs or has stopped doing so. It just means they're not as central to its air defense strategy.
> Have you heard of the stinger, that the Ukrainians are using to great effect? The US also has the patriot and aegis systems which are really good air defense missiles. That’s not including THAAD, etc.
Not like the Soviet Union did. The article I'm trying to paraphrase said that SAMs were far more integral to Soviet air defense strategy than they were to Western air defense, which put more emphasis on using fighter aircraft for air defense than having the Army deploy different SAM systems for every need. Because the Soviets relied more on SAMs, then the West had to put more emphasis on counter-SAM weapons (which the Soviets has far less need to do).
Also the article noted that the exception is Western navies, which the article said were in a more similar situation to the Soviet Army. That's why the more capable US SAM systems have naval lineage.
The same author in this video (he was being interviewed, towards the end of the video) mentioned the lack of SEAD compared to the west:
"If the VKS had the large-scale organizational capabilities we'd previously assumed, then they'd have a straightforward SEAD approach (involving strength in numbers and some moderate SEAD sophistication), though it might lose aircraft (perhaps due to comparably low SEAD sophistication, I don't know). Then, having eliminated the SAMs, they could fly higher, in larger numbers. So it's weird that they don't do that. This is circumstantial evidence that they aren't capable of this type of SEAD, and this in turn is more evidence for my tentative conclusion that they might be incapable of air operations of more than a few planes."
That's what I got out of the SEAD comments in TFA.
[thank you for the clarification --they had R.A.D.A.R. but apparently it was behind Allies' tech]
While electronic warfare was still in relative infancy, radio and RADAR jamming and chaff (known then to the Allies as "Window") were widely used. However, prior to the widespread development and use of guided weapons (e.g. homing anti-radiation missiles) it was very difficult to precisely strike small SEAD targets (semi-mobile RADAR units, AAA batteries) without needing to first close within range of low-level AAA defenses.
The Allies did use bombing raids on Luftwaffe airfields as a way to draw out fighters, as well as wide-ranging fighter sweeps that would attempt to catch fighters on the ground. But these had serious limitations: the Germans had very effective short-range AAA deployed around their airfields which inflicted serious losses on ground-attack missions, and airfields at the time were very difficult to damage. Especially prior to the widespread use of jet aircraft with higher takeoff and landing speeds and weights, an airfield could basically be just that - a field - and filling in bomb craters to return a runway to active use was straightforward. That means the only effective target was the planes on the ground themselves, and without guided munitions the only way to effectively target airplanes on the ground was to strike at low altitude and thus come within range of the strong AAA defenses. This would begin to change later in the war with the growing use of (unguided) rockets that allowed for something of a standoff distance (compared to dive bombing), but nothing like the reach of a modern PGM.
I think there's a necessary combination of factors that came together in the Vietnam and Arab-Israeli wars to give birth to SEAD in its modern form:
- Strong enemy air defenses in the form of SAM batteries
- Unacceptable attrition due to said defenses
- Increased weapon accuracy to allow effective targeting of specific threats (e.g. a specific enemy RADAR or SAM site) either via homing (Shrike/Standard ARM) or TV/laser guidance (Bullpup/Walleye/Paveway)
- Early integrated circuits allowing for more complicated and effective electronic warfare equipment (warning receivers, jammers, homing seekers, etc)
So the risk of an expensive bomber was greater than the risk of distributed Anti Aircraft guns, which are cheap in comparison to bombers.
I guess we should look at the cost of the bom for a tank, not what government pays for it.
Not that tanks are cheap but I think manifacturing cost is substantially lower than 10m.
The MiG 21 cost less to procure than a BMP-1 armoured personnel carrier if Wikipedia [1] is to be believed [2]. A BMP is not a tank and can be assumed to be less expensive than one.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikoyan-Gurevich_MiG-21#Cost
[2] which is in this case probably is seeing as how this is not a politically sensitive subject
But if they can't import the latest and greatest parts to make T-90Ms or T-72B3Ms....they have such a huge stockpile of "good enough" older T-72s in storage, they can just use those with a minor refurbishment period. With what we've seen of their tactics and (lack of) skills, it won't seriously impact their battlefield results to field early 1980s-era tank technology.
Against M1 Abrams it isn’t even going to be a battle and they don’t have enough Armatas to make a difference.
I question the use of tanks for anything beyond a support / artillery role at this point. All tanks seem highly vulnerable to both air and Javelin-like AT.
I think there was a US report a few years back about how modern tanks are no longer really the centerpiece of the battlefield anymore. Similar to how the battleship was thought to be the centerpiece at the beginning of WW2 and then it quickly became apparent it was the aircraft carrier.
That's due more to shit tactics (exacerbated by the early spring thaw that has limited off-road movement) than to any specific limitations of their hardware. There is VERY little footage of dismounted infantry screening Russian tanks, or competent employment of other recon assets. Look up some ANNA News footage embedded with the Syrian Arab Army in Jhobar, a Damascus suburb. It took the Syrians years of errors/casualties, but they eventually learned to storm dug-in fanatical enemies in urban environments, and they did it with crappier T-72s than the Russians are fielding now. There is a plethora of modern ATGMs dumped into Syrian insurgent hands too.
>>>Against M1 Abrams it isn’t even going to be a battle
That's a crew quality issue as well. A T-90 or T-72B3 is absolutely a threat to an Abrams.
>>>I question the use of tanks for anything beyond a support / artillery role at this point.
Increasing urbanization/population densities worldwide make sweeping wars of maneuver across open terrain less viable. Tanks are useful in urban environments, but require well-trained soldiers experienced in combined arms (German Kampfgruppe in Stalingrad, US Army-Marine teams in Fallujah).
>>>All tanks seem highly vulnerable to both air and Javelin-like AT.
As my sister comment touches on, this is changing as tank protection moves away from thick slabs of passive armor, to every tank fielding active protection systems such as the Israeli Trophy ( https://youtu.be/6aA9HsmLHBQ ). <-- also some of the coolest footage of shaped charge warheads detonating.
Combine an APS with a laser air-defense system either on another vehicle (current tech: https://www.armyrecognition.com/weapons_defence_industry_mil... ) or on the tank's turret (future tech), and these threats are moderately neutralized.
Then the advantages of the main battle tank will be retained: mobility, protection, and firepower.